Comment

Hydroponics ยท Nutrient guide

Best Hydroponic Nutrients: 7 Types With Target ppm

A complete hydroponic mix supplies 14 mineral elements; the Hoagland benchmark gives about 210 ppm nitrogen and 235 ppm potassium at full strength. Seven product types compared, with pH, EC and oxygen targets from university trials.

Authored by Farmonaut Research & Content Team
Reviewed and verified by Farmonaut Agricultural Experts Team
Updated 12 November 2026 ยท 14 min read
Sentinel-2 Satellite View Of Greenhouse Vegetable Farms And Fields Between Leamington And Kingsville, Ontario, Canada
Sentinel-2 view of Greenhouse vegetable farms and fields between Leamington and Kingsville, Ontario, Canada. Contains modified Copernicus Sentinel data, processed in Google Earth Engine.

Key takeaways

  • Full-strength Hoagland solution carries about 210 ppm N, 235 ppm K, 200 ppm Ca, 64 ppm S, 48.6 ppm Mg and 31 ppm P (Hoagland and Arnon, 1950).
  • Cornell lettuce trials used a near half-strength solution at pH 5.6 to 6.0 and EC 1.15 to 1.25 mS/cm with reverse-osmosis water.
  • Penn State advises keeping nutrient solution pH between 5.0 and 7.0; high pH is the most common cause of iron deficiency.
  • Two-part products keep calcium apart from phosphate and sulfate; Kentucky guidance uses two stock tanks for the same reason.
  • Kentucky budgets put break-even at about US$0.93 per lettuce head for a 3,000 sq ft greenhouse (2016 estimate).
In this article
  1. Best hydroponic nutrients at a glance
  2. What hydroponic nutrients must supply
  3. Target ppm: the Hoagland benchmark
  4. The 7 types of hydroponic nutrients, compared
  5. How to choose hydroponic nutrients for your crop
  6. PH, EC and oxygen targets
  7. Nutrient deficiency symptoms and fixes
  8. Costs and returns in hydroponic lettuce
  9. Water, energy and yield trade-offs
  10. How common is hydroponic production in the US
  11. How to mix a nutrient solution, step by step
  12. Where field crop monitoring fits
  13. How we chose and checked
  14. FAQ

The best hydroponic nutrients are complete, water-soluble mixes that supply all 14 mineral elements plants take from their roots, at a strength your crop can use. A classic benchmark is the Hoagland solution, with about 210 ppm nitrogen and 235 ppm potassium at full strength (Hoagland and Arnon, University of California, 1950). Cornell’s lettuce research used a solution close to half that strength, kept at pH 5.6 to 6.0.

This guide compares seven types of nutrient product, from two-part mineral concentrates to organic liquids, and says which grower each one suits. It gives target ppm, pH and EC figures from university trials, a deficiency table, and a calculator to test what nutrients and other costs mean for the price you need per lettuce head.

Best hydroponic nutrients at a glance

There is no single best bottle. The right product depends on your system, your water and the crop. The table ranks the seven common types by how many growers they suit, from the widest fit to the narrowest.

Type Best for Main strength Main catch
1. Two-part liquid Most home and small commercial systems Calcium kept apart from sulfate and phosphate Two bottles to measure
2. Dry salts, two tanks Commercial greenhouses Lowest cost per ppm, full control Needs scales and a recipe
3. One-part complete Beginners, small leafy setups One scoop or one pour Less room to adjust
4. Three-part liquid Fruiting crops with growth stages Ratios change by stage More steps, more error
5. Leafy-green formula Lettuce, herbs, microgreens Nitrogen-led, lower EC Too weak for tomatoes
6. Fruiting formula Tomatoes, peppers, cucumbers More potassium and calcium Too strong for greens
7. Organic liquid Substrate systems, organic niche Plant- or animal-based inputs Biofilm and slower release

Two add-ons sit outside the list because they fix one gap rather than feed a crop: calcium-magnesium supplements for soft or reverse-osmosis water, and pH adjusters. Many products sold as boosters add little beyond what a complete mix already supplies.

What hydroponic nutrients must supply

Plants need 17 essential elements, according to Penn State Extension. Carbon, hydrogen and oxygen come from air and water. The other 14 must come from the solution in a soilless system.

Penn State splits them into two groups by how much the plant needs:

  • Macronutrients: nitrogen, phosphorus, potassium, calcium, magnesium and sulfur.
  • Micronutrients: iron, manganese, zinc, boron, molybdenum, chlorine, copper and nickel.

The same Penn State table gives the share of plant dry weight for each element. Nitrogen makes up about 2 to 4%, potassium about 2%, calcium about 1.5%, sulfur 0.5%, and phosphorus and magnesium about 0.4% each. Iron and manganese are near 0.02%. These shares explain why a good mix is heavy in nitrogen and potassium and light in trace metals.

Macronutrients and what each one does

  • Nitrogen (N): builds amino acids, proteins and chlorophyll. Plants take it as nitrate or ammonium.
  • Phosphorus (P): part of ATP, the energy carrier, and of cell membranes and DNA. Supports roots and flowering.
  • Potassium (K): controls water pressure in cells and switches on enzymes. Fruit quality depends on it.
  • Calcium (Ca): holds cell walls together. A shortage shows as tipburn in lettuce and blossom end rot in tomatoes and zucchini.
  • Magnesium (Mg): sits at the centre of the chlorophyll molecule.
  • Sulfur (S): part of some amino acids and proteins.

Micronutrients in small doses

Trace elements work as enzyme helpers. Iron and copper move electrons in photosynthesis and respiration. Molybdenum is needed to reduce nitrate. Boron supports cell division. A complete product supplies them in chelated or salt form. Adding extra micronutrients without a test can push them to toxic levels, so add them only when a water or tissue test points to a gap.

Target ppm: the Hoagland benchmark

Most hydroponic recipes trace back to work at the University of California. W.F. Gericke developed solution culture in the 1920s, and Hoagland and Arnon published a complete solution in 1938, according to the USDA National Agricultural Library. Their 1950 circular is still a standard reference.

The full-strength values below are taken from the published Hoagland concentrations. Use them as a yardstick, not a recipe. Lettuce and herbs often do well at about half strength, while fruiting crops in full production need more potassium.

Element Full strength (ppm) Half strength (ppm)
Nitrogen 210 105
Potassium 235 118
Calcium 200 (160 in solution 2) 80 to 100
Sulfur 64 32
Magnesium 48.6 24
Phosphorus 31 16
Iron 1 to 5 0.5 to 2.5
Boron, manganese 0.5 each (1950) 0.25 each
Zinc 0.05 0.025
Copper 0.02 0.01
Molybdenum 0.011 0.006

To check a product, read the guaranteed analysis on its label and the dilution rate. Then work out the ppm it gives in your tank. A product that lands near this pattern, scaled for your crop, is a sound base.

Chart

Macronutrients in full-strength Hoagland solution

ppm (mg per litre) in the finished solution, solution 1

062125188250Potassium235Nitrogen210Calcium200Sulfur64Magnesium49Phosphorus31Source: Hoagland and Arnon, The Water-Culture Method for Growing Plants Without Soil (University of California, 1950), astabulated in the Hoagland solution reference.
062125188250Potassium235Nitrogen210Calcium200Sulfur64Magnesium49Phosphorus31Source: Hoagland and Arnon, The Water-Culture Method forGrowing Plants Without Soil (University of California, 1950),as tabulated in the Hoagland solution reference.
Potassium and nitrogen dominate; phosphorus is needed at about one seventh of the nitrogen level.

The 7 types of hydroponic nutrients, compared

Each type below has a “Best for” line and the points to check before you buy. Brand names change often, so the list compares formats and what they deliver rather than labels.

1. Two-part liquid concentrates

Best for: most home systems and small commercial NFT or deep water culture setups.

Calcium nitrate is kept in part A, and phosphates, sulfates and micronutrients in part B. Kept apart, they cannot form insoluble calcium phosphate or gypsum in the bottle. University of Kentucky guidance on hydroponic lettuce uses the same idea at farm scale: one tank holds calcium nitrate and a second holds the rest, mixed only as they enter the irrigation line. Always add part A and part B to the water separately, stirring between them.

2. Dry salts mixed in two stock tanks

Best for: commercial greenhouses that use a lot of solution.

Growers buy single salts such as calcium nitrate, potassium nitrate, monopotassium phosphate and magnesium sulfate, plus a chelated micronutrient blend. They dissolve them into concentrated A and B stocks and dose with injectors. This is the cheapest route per unit of nutrient and gives full control over ratios. It also needs accurate scales, a written recipe and a water test, because errors scale up fast.

3. One-part complete powders or liquids

Best for: beginners, classrooms and small leafy-green kits.

All elements come in one product, usually a powder with calcium nitrate supplied separately or in a form that stays soluble at the label rate. The appeal is simplicity. The trade-off is that you cannot change the calcium-to-potassium balance without a second product.

4. Three-part liquid systems

Best for: growers of tomatoes, peppers or strawberries who change ratios by growth stage.

A grow part, a bloom part and a micronutrient part are mixed in different shares through the season. More nitrogen supports leafy growth early. More potassium and phosphorus support flowering and fruit. The flexibility helps experienced growers. For a beginner, three bottles mean three ways to get the dose wrong.

5. Leafy-green formulas

Best for: lettuce, spinach, basil, kale and microgreens.

These products lean on nitrogen and run at lower EC. In Cornell University’s lettuce trials, the solution closely resembled half-strength Hoagland, with EC held at 1,150 to 1,250 ยตS/cm (1.15 to 1.25 mS/cm) using reverse-osmosis water, according to A.J. Both’s summary of ten years of Cornell lettuce research. Plants reached about 150 g of shoot weight 35 days after seeding.

6. Fruiting-crop formulas

Best for: tomatoes, cucumbers and peppers in substrate or NFT.

Fruit draws heavily on potassium and calcium, so these mixes carry more of both. Balance matters as much as the total. Penn State gives the example of a tomato recipe calling for 190 ppm nitrogen and 205 ppm potassium. If 2,050 ppm potassium goes in by mistake, the excess can block nitrogen uptake, and the crop shows nitrogen deficiency although nitrogen was added.

7. Organic liquid nutrients

Best for: growers selling to an organic niche who use substrate-based systems.

These come from plant extracts, fish or other natural sources. Microbes must break them down before roots can use some of the nitrogen. A 2024 study in Frontiers in Plant Science grew lettuce with one liquid organic fertilizer in four systems. Lettuce in substrate-based root pouch containers grew 29% to 60% more than in NFT on measures such as leaf area and fresh weight. The authors concluded that the product suited substrate systems, and that other fertilizers and crops still need testing. Organic certification of hydroponic crops also differs by country, so check the rules where you sell.

How to choose hydroponic nutrients for your crop

Work through these five questions before you buy.

  1. What is in your water? Test the source water for EC, pH, alkalinity, calcium, magnesium and sodium. Hard water already supplies calcium and magnesium. Reverse-osmosis water supplies none, so you may need a calcium-magnesium supplement.
  2. What are you growing? Leafy crops need a nitrogen-led mix at lower strength. Fruiting crops need more potassium and calcium.
  3. Which system? Recirculating systems such as NFT and deep water culture favour fully soluble mineral products. Organic liquids work better in substrate systems that drain to waste.
  4. How much will you mix? Bottled liquids suit small tanks. Dry salts become much cheaper as volume grows.
  5. Can you measure? Any product needs a pH meter and an EC meter. Without them, even the best nutrients will fail.

Read the label for the guaranteed analysis, the form of nitrogen (nitrate versus ammonium), the chelate used for iron, and the mixing order. Follow the label rate and local rules on fertilizer storage and disposal. In the European Union, CE-marked fertilising products must meet Regulation (EU) 2019/1009; elsewhere, check your state, provincial or national rules, and get professional advice for a commercial plan.

PH, EC and oxygen targets

Nutrients only work when the solution chemistry is right. Three readings matter most.

PH

Penn State advises keeping nutrient solution pH between 5.0 and 7.0. Cornell held lettuce at 5.6 to 6.0. Above that range, iron becomes less available, and Penn State names high pH as the most common cause of iron deficiency. A hydroponic solution has none of the buffering of soil, so its pH drifts as plants feed, the Kentucky guide notes. Check it daily in small systems.

EC

Electrical conductivity measures the total dissolved salts. It does not show which nutrient is high or low, only the total. Cornell kept lettuce at about 1.2 mS/cm with pure water and about 1.65 mS/cm in its demonstration greenhouse on municipal water, because tap water adds its own salts. Fruiting crops usually run higher. Rising EC with falling water level means plants are drinking more than they feed; top up with plain water. Falling EC means they are feeding faster; add concentrate.

Dissolved oxygen and temperature

Roots need oxygen to take up nutrients. Cornell’s research recommended at least 4 mg/L dissolved oxygen for lettuce in deep flow systems and saw severe stress below 2 mg/L. Warm water holds less oxygen, so keep the reservoir cool and aerated.

Nutrient deficiency symptoms and fixes

Where a symptom appears tells you a lot. Nitrogen, phosphorus and potassium are mobile in the plant, so their shortages show first on older leaves, as NC State Extension explains. Calcium and iron do not move easily, so their shortages show on new growth.

Nutrient First sign Where Usual fix
Nitrogen Pale green to yellow leaves, slow growth Older leaves Raise EC; check for potassium excess
Phosphorus Dark leaves with purple undersides Older leaves Check solution and root temperature
Potassium Yellow, scorched leaf edges Older leaves Raise K share in the mix
Calcium Tipburn, blossom end rot New leaves, fruit Add airflow; check pH and humidity
Magnesium Yellow between veins Older leaves Add magnesium sulfate; correct pH
Iron Yellow new leaves, green veins New leaves Lower pH; use a stable chelate
Sulfur Even yellowing Younger leaves Check the mix supplies sulfate

Calcium problems are often about water movement rather than supply. Penn State links calcium deficiency to low airflow, heat and humidity as well as low pH. For lettuce in greenhouses, it suggests horizontal airflow of 0.3 to 1 m/s at plant level to help prevent tipburn.

Too much of one element can look like too little of another. Excess potassium can cause nitrogen shortage, and high phosphorus can block zinc and iron, according to NC State’s nutrient table. Before you add more of anything, check pH, EC and the recipe.

Why leaves turn yellow when nitrogen runs short, and how growers correct it.

โ–ถ Why leaves turn yellow when nitrogen runs short, and how growers correct it. ยท 12:32

Costs and returns in hydroponic lettuce

Nutrients are one input among many. The Kentucky guide, using Ohio State lettuce budgets updated in 2016, estimated break-even costs for a 3,000 sq ft greenhouse with eight harvests a year and 5,900 marketable heads per harvest. Variable costs came to US$0.74 per head and fixed costs to US$0.19, a total of about US$0.93 per head including operator labour. Labour alone averaged about 1,500 hours a year.

The same guide puts the cost of a production-ready greenhouse above US$10 per sq ft, excluding land, and gross returns at US$10 to US$25 per sq ft of production space a season, depending on crop quality and market. These are budget estimates from 2016, not current quotes. Prices for inputs and lettuce change, so use your own figures in the calculator.

Try the numbers for your own farm below.

Calculator

What price per head covers your costs?

Enter your own heads, costs and selling price.

heads

per year

US$

US$

US$

US$
944US$ margin per year over all costs (negative means a loss)
  • Break-even price per head: 0.9 US$
  • Heads per year: 47,200 heads
  • Nutrient spend per year: 2,360 US$
  • Nutrients as share of total cost: 5 %

Example values only, set near break-even; they are not a benchmark or a forecast. The defaults echo the Kentucky budget (US$0.74 variable and US$0.19 fixed per head, 2016 estimate) with nutrients shown as a separate line. Replace every figure with your own costs and today’s price.

Water, energy and yield trade-offs

A study of lettuce in Yuma, Arizona, compared hydroponic and field production using crop budgets and engineering estimates (Barbosa et al., 2015). Hydroponics gave about 41 kg/mยฒ a year against 3.9 kg/mยฒ in the field, roughly 11 times the yield per area. It used about 20 litres of water per kg against 250 litres. It also needed about 82 times more energy per kg, mostly for heating and cooling, then lighting.

Chart

Water used per kg of lettuce

Litres per kg, Yuma, Arizona, modelled estimates

06212518825020Hydroponic250FieldSource: Barbosa et al., International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health (2015).
06212518825020Hydroponic250FieldSource: Barbosa et al., International Journal of EnvironmentalResearch and Public Health (2015).
Hydroponic lettuce used about one twelfth of the water per kg, but far more energy.

The authors concluded that energy cost was the main hurdle, and that sites with cheap renewable power suit hydroponics best. For more on that side of indoor growing, see our page on vertical farming energy use per kg.

How common is hydroponic production in the US

The USDA Economic Research Service reviewed controlled environment agriculture (CEA) in a January 2024 report, using the Census of Horticultural Specialties. The number of CEA operations with sales of US$10,000 or more grew from 1,015 in 1998 to 2,994 in 2019.

Chart

US controlled environment agriculture operations

Operations with sales of US$10,000 or more, Census of Horticultural Specialties years

07501,5002,2503,0001998200920142019CEA operations 2,994Source: USDA Economic Research Service, EIB-264 (January 2024), Figure 2, from NASS Census of Horticultural Specialties data.
07501,5002,2503,0001998200920142019CEA operations2,994Source: USDA Economic Research Service, EIB-264 (January2024), Figure 2, from NASS Census of Horticultural Specialtiesdata.
The number of CEA operations nearly tripled between 1998 and 2019.

Within CEA, hydroponics carries the main greenhouse vegetables. In 2019, about 67% of CEA cucumbers, 66% of CEA lettuce and 61% of CEA tomatoes were grown hydroponically. The shares were lower for fresh-cut herbs (23%), strawberries (16%) and peppers (3%). Total hydroponic food crop volume rose from about 3.7 million cwt in 2009 to 4.2 million cwt in 2019.

Chart

Share of US CEA crop volume grown hydroponically

Percent of each crop’s controlled environment production, 2019

0%20%40%60%80%Cucumbers67%Lettuce66%Tomatoes61%Fresh-cut herbs23%Strawberries16%Peppers3%Source: USDA Economic Research Service, EIB-264 (January 2024), from the 2019 Census of Horticultural Specialties.
0%20%40%60%80%Cucumbers67%Lettuce66%Tomatoes61%Fresh-cut herbs23%Strawberries16%Peppers3%Source: USDA Economic Research Service, EIB-264 (January2024), from the 2019 Census of Horticultural Specialties.
Hydroponics carries most CEA cucumbers, lettuce and tomatoes, but few peppers.
Small farm business ideas, including growing microgreens on a shelf.

โ–ถ Small farm business ideas, including growing microgreens on a shelf. ยท 6:03

How to mix a nutrient solution, step by step

  1. Test the water. Note the starting EC and pH. Subtract the calcium and magnesium the water already supplies.
  2. Fill the reservoir to about 80% with water at room temperature.
  3. Add part A (or the calcium product) at the label rate. Stir well.
  4. Add part B separately. Stir again. Never mix concentrates together before they are diluted.
  5. Add any supplement such as calcium-magnesium only if your water test shows a gap.
  6. Top up to the final volume and measure EC. Adjust with more concentrate or more water.
  7. Adjust pH last, in small steps, waiting a few minutes between doses. Wear gloves and eye protection with pH-down acids.
  8. Log the readings. Recheck pH and EC daily in small tanks and replace the solution on a regular schedule.

Where field crop monitoring fits

Hydroponic houses are managed with meters, sensors and dosing controllers. Many growers also farm open fields, where nutrient stress is harder to see. Satellite vegetation maps can show which parts of a field are paler or slower than the rest, so you know where to take a tissue or soil sample. Farmonaut Satellite + AI Farm Monitoring System provides those maps for field crops; it does not measure solution chemistry inside a greenhouse.

Related pages on our site: farm management dashboard, satellite and weather data API, produce traceability, farm carbon footprinting, farm vehicle fleet tracking and the crop monitoring web app.

How satellite NDVI maps show crop stress across a field before it is easy to see.

โ–ถ How satellite NDVI maps show crop stress across a field before it is easy to see. ยท 4:09

How we chose and checked

We grouped products by format and use rather than brand, because labels and formulas change. We ranked the seven types by how many growers each suits. Every target number comes from a named university, government or peer-reviewed source, linked in the text and listed at the end. Cost figures are dated budget estimates, not current market prices.

FAQ

What are the best hydroponic nutrients for leafy greens?

A nitrogen-led complete mix at about half Hoagland strength works well. Cornell’s lettuce trials held EC near 1.2 mS/cm and pH at 5.6 to 6.0, with calcium nitrate supplied separately.

Can you use hydroponic nutrients in soil?

Yes, at a lower rate. They are soluble mineral fertilizers. Soil also holds and releases its own nutrients, so test the soil first and follow the label to avoid salt build-up.

How often should I change the nutrient solution?

Many small growers replace it every one to three weeks, and sooner if EC climbs while plants look stressed. Daily pH and EC checks tell you more than a fixed date.

Are organic hydroponic nutrients as good as mineral ones?

They can work, mainly in substrate systems. A 2024 study found lettuce grew better with a liquid organic product in substrate containers than in NFT. Mineral salts are easier to control in recirculating systems.

Why are my hydroponic plants yellow?

Yellow older leaves usually point to nitrogen or magnesium. Yellow new leaves with green veins often mean iron, and high pH is the usual cause. Check pH and EC before adding nutrients.

Do I need a cal-mag supplement?

Only if your water lacks calcium and magnesium, as reverse-osmosis water does. Hard tap water may already supply enough, so test it first.

Authored by: Farmonaut Research & Content Team

Reviewed and verified by: Farmonaut Agricultural Experts Team

Reviewed November 2026 against Penn State Extension (2026), Hoagland and Arnon (1950), Cornell lettuce research (Both, 2003), University of Kentucky hydroponic lettuce guidance, NC State Extension, USDA NAL, USDA ERS EIB-264 (2024), Barbosa et al. (2015) and Frontiers in Plant Science (2024).

Farmonaut crop monitoring

Advise growers with field-level crop maps

For open-field clients, Farmonaut shows satellite vegetation maps for each field through the season, so you can see where to sample and what to check next.

Open The Farmonaut Crop Monitoring Web AppGet The Farmonaut App On Google PlayGet The Farmonaut App On The App Store
Farmonaut Web App With A Satellite Crop Health Map

Sources

  1. Penn State Extension, Hydroponics Systems and Principles of Plant Nutrition: Essential Nutrients, Function, Deficiency, and Excess (updated February 2026): extension.psu.edu
  2. Hoagland, D.R. and Arnon, D.I., The Water-Culture Method for Growing Plants Without Soil, University of California Circular 347 (1950): archive.org
  3. Hoagland solution, table of 1933, 1938 and 1950 concentrations (Wikipedia): en.wikipedia.org
  4. USDA National Agricultural Library, Hydroponics: nal.usda.gov
  5. A.J. Both, Ten Years of Hydroponic Lettuce Research, Cornell University (2003): haifa-group.com
  6. University of Kentucky Center for Crop Diversification, Hydroponic Lettuce (CCD-CP-63): ccd.uky.edu
  7. Frontiers in Plant Science, Evaluation of hydroponic systems for organic lettuce production in controlled environment (2024): frontiersin.org
  8. NC State Extension, Extension Gardener Handbook, Soils and Plant Nutrients: content.ces.ncsu.edu
  9. Barbosa et al., Comparison of Land, Water, and Energy Requirements of Lettuce Grown Using Hydroponic vs. Conventional Agricultural Methods (2015): ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
  10. USDA Economic Research Service, Trends, Insights, and Future Prospects for Production in Controlled Environment Agriculture and Agrivoltaics Systems, EIB-264 (January 2024): ers.usda.gov
  11. Regulation (EU) 2019/1009 on EU fertilising products (EUR-Lex): eur-lex.europa.eu


Discussion

Questions, corrections or field experience? Share them below. First-time comments are reviewed before they appear, and your email is never published.

No comments yet. Be the first to add a question or your experience.

Leave a comment

Farmonaut Farmonaut Trusted by 200,000+ users and 500+ businesses 200,000+ users trust us Get started