Comment

Underground mining ยท Environmental impacts

Subsurface Mining Environmental Impacts and Disadvantages

Underground mining disturbs less land than an open pit, but it causes subsidence, groundwater damage and most coal mine methane, and it costs more per tonne: U.S. underground coal mines produced 3.24 short tons per employee hour in 2024 against 8.94 at surface mines (EIA).

Authored by Farmonaut Research & Content Team
Reviewed and verified by Farmonaut Mining & Mineral Exploration Team
Updated 5 November 2026 ยท 14 min read
Sentinel-2 Satellite View Of Northern Appalachian Longwall Coal District, Greene County, Pennsylvania
Sentinel-2 true-colour composite of Northern Appalachian longwall coal district, Greene County, Pennsylvania (39.83ยฐN, 80.25ยฐW). Contains modified Copernicus Sentinel data, 2022 to 2026, processed in Google Earth Engine.

Key takeaways

  • Active and abandoned coal mines produced about 7% of U.S. methane emissions in 2021 (EIA); underground mines are the vast majority of coal mine methane (EPA).
  • Coal accounted for more than 40 Mt of global methane in 2024, including over 4 Mt from abandoned mines (IEA Global Methane Tracker 2025).
  • Above the multi-level Newstan Colliery in New South Wales the ground dropped by up to five metres in places.
  • U.S. underground mines produced 206.2 of 512.5 million short tons of coal in 2024, about 40% (EIA Annual Coal Report).
  • U.S. rules require underground coal mines to prevent subsidence damage or plan subsidence in a predictable, controlled way (30 CFR 817.121).
In this article
  1. What subsurface mining is and where it is used
  2. Disadvantages of subsurface mining at a glance
  3. Subsurface mining environmental impacts on land: subsidence
  4. Groundwater disturbance and acid mine drainage
  5. Methane, dust and air quality underground
  6. Waste rock, tailings and energy use
  7. Worker safety and cost disadvantages
  8. Subsurface mining pros and cons compared with surface mining
  9. How does surface mining affect the environment differently?
  10. What happens when a mine moves from underground to surface mining
  11. How to reduce the environmental impact of underground mining
  12. What consultants should check on an underground project
  13. Frequently asked questions

The main subsurface mining environmental impacts are ground subsidence above the workings, disturbed and acidified groundwater, methane and dust released through ventilation shafts, and waste rock or tailings at the surface. Underground mines also cost more per tonne and expose crews to more hazards than open pits. Methane is the clearest number: the U.S. Energy Information Administration says active and abandoned coal mines produced about 7% of U.S. methane emissions in 2021 (EIA), and the U.S. EPA says underground mines account for the vast majority of coal mine methane in the United States and worldwide (EPA Coal Mine Methane Outreach Program). This guide ranks each disadvantage by where it shows up, how it is controlled, and what a consultant should check, with a subsidence screening calculator and a side-by-side comparison with surface mining.

What subsurface mining is and where it is used

Subsurface mining, usually called underground mining, reaches a deposit through shafts, declines (sloping tunnels) or adits (horizontal entries) instead of stripping off the overburden, the soil and rock that cover it. In U.S. coal, the EIA describes surface mining as the usual choice when coal lies less than 200 feet (about 60 m) down and underground mining when it lies deeper; some underground mines are thousands of feet deep, with tunnels running for miles from the shafts (EIA, Mining and transportation of coal).

The main methods differ in how much rock they leave behind, and that drives most of their environmental footprint:

  • Room-and-pillar: the miner cuts a grid of rooms and leaves pillars of coal or ore to hold up the roof. Surface movement is usually small while the pillars stand, but old pillars can fail decades later.
  • Longwall: a shearer cuts a long face, often a few hundred metres wide, and the roof is allowed to collapse behind the moving supports. It recovers most of the seam and produces planned subsidence at the surface.
  • Continuous mining: a machine cuts coal in rooms and entries, often in a room-and-pillar layout.
  • Stoping (cut-and-fill, sublevel and shrinkage stoping): used for steep metal veins and orebodies; voids are often backfilled with waste rock or cemented tailings.
  • Block and panel caving: the orebody is undercut so it breaks and falls under its own weight; the ground above caves to surface by design.

Underground methods are common for deep coal and for vein-hosted metals such as gold and silver; our ranking of the top silver producing companies covers many operators that run such mines, and our guide to types of ore deposits explains which deposit shapes suit which method. For definitions of both families side by side, see surface mining vs subsurface mining.

Disadvantages of subsurface mining at a glance

The table ranks the disadvantages from the most widespread environmental effect to the operational ones. “Where it shows up” tells a consultant which baseline data to collect first.

Rank Disadvantage Main cause Where it shows up Usual control
1 Ground subsidence Roof collapse behind longwall or caving; pillar failure Surface dips, cracked roads and buildings, changed drainage Pillar design, narrower panels, backfill, planned subsidence and repair
2 Groundwater disturbance and acid mine drainage Dewatering; air and water reaching sulfide minerals Lower water tables, acidic metal-rich discharges, sometimes decades after closure Water balance monitoring, sealing, neutralisation and treatment
3 Methane and greenhouse gas Gas released from coal and rock, vented by fans Ventilation shafts, degasification wells, abandoned mines Drainage and capture, flaring or use, ventilation air methane oxidation
4 Dust, silica and diesel exhaust Cutting, blasting, haulage in confined space Mine air, worker health Ventilation, water sprays, exposure limits, cleaner equipment
5 Waste rock and tailings Development rock and processing waste Dumps and storage facilities at surface Backfilling voids, lined storage, cover systems
6 Worker safety risk Roof falls, gas, fire, flooding Underground workings Ground support, gas monitoring, refuge chambers, training
7 Higher cost and lower productivity Shafts, ventilation, pumping, ground support Cost per tonne, project economics Mechanisation, selective mining of higher grades

Subsurface mining environmental impacts on land: subsidence

Subsidence is the sinking of the ground surface as rock above an underground opening moves down to fill the void. With longwall and caving methods it is expected and planned; with room-and-pillar it is reduced but can appear suddenly when pillars or roof rock fail years later.

The scale can be large. Above the multi-level Newstan Colliery in New South Wales, Australia, the surface dropped by as much as five metres in places, and a single longwall operation can affect more than 200 acres (81 ha) (longwall mining overview). The same overview records that longwall panels near Douglas Park Drive in the Sydney region destabilised the road and closed it for four weeks. New South Wales runs a government agency, Subsidence Advisory NSW, solely to support property owners in areas where subsidence from underground coal mining may occur.

Subsidence matters to the environment as well as to buildings. Cracks in the ground can drain streams and wetlands into the rock below, change which way surface water flows, and tilt pipelines and farm drains. Mountain slopes above longwalls tend to show more visible subsidence than valleys.

U.S. law addresses it directly. Federal performance standards for underground coal mines require operators either to prevent subsidence from causing material damage to the extent technologically and economically feasible, or to use mining technology that produces planned subsidence in a predictable and controlled manner and then minimise damage to homes and structures (30 CFR 817.121). Engineers limit subsidence by widening the chain pillars between panels, narrowing the extracted panels, cutting a thinner slice of the seam, and considering the depth and strength of the overlying rock.

The calculator below gives a first screening estimate of how much the ground could drop over a longwall panel and how wide an area could move. It is not a substitute for a site subsidence prediction.

Calculator

Longwall subsidence screening estimate

Enter your seam, panel and depth to see how far and how wide the ground could move.

m

ratio

m

m

m

ratio
1.5 mmaximum possible ground drop
  • Panel area mined (ha): 60.0
  • Width of ground that could move (m): 550
  • Surface area that could move (ha): 123.8
  • Surface area that could move (acres): 306

Screening only, not a subsidence prediction. All defaults are round example values, not benchmarks. The subsidence factor (share of extraction height that reaches the surface) and the draw ratio (horizontal reach of movement per metre of depth, the tangent of the angle of draw) are site specific: use values from your geotechnical engineer or the regulator’s guideline for your coalfield.

Groundwater disturbance and acid mine drainage

Underground mines must be kept dry, so they pump water out continuously. That lowers the water table around the mine, can dry springs and shallow wells, and sends large volumes of mine water to the surface for treatment. When pumping stops after closure, the workings slowly flood again, and the rising water can pick up acidity and metals on the way.

Acid mine drainage is the best-known form of this damage. The U.S. EPA describes it as highly acidic water rich in heavy metals, formed when surface water and shallow groundwater react with rocks that contain sulfur-bearing minerals to make sulfuric acid; bacteria can speed up the reaction, and the EPA lists it as the most common water problem at abandoned mines, alongside alkaline and metal mine drainage (EPA, Abandoned Mine Drainage). The mineral usually to blame is pyrite, iron sulfide. Where drainage has been neutralised along its path but still carries metals, specialists call it neutral mine drainage (acid mine drainage overview).

South Africa’s Witwatersrand goldfields show how long this lasts. More than a century of mining left a deep network of abandoned shafts that are gradually filling with water, and the pyrite in the rock turns that water acidic; the area lies about 30 km from the Cradle of Humankind World Heritage Site (EARTH Magazine).

U.S. rules for underground coal mines require operators to minimise disturbance of the hydrologic balance and to prefer mining and reclamation practices that prevent water pollution over later water treatment (30 CFR 817.41). For treatment options once acidity appears, our guide to acid mine drainage solutions compares passive and active systems. Rainfall records matter for the water balance too; a satellite weather API is one way to feed rainfall data into a site model.

The seven environmental impacts of mining, explained in clay

โ–ถ The seven environmental impacts of mining, explained in clay ยท 2:31

Methane, dust and air quality underground

Coal holds methane in its pores. In an underground mine that gas can explode, so it is diluted by large fans and blown out of ventilation shafts as ventilation air methane, or drawn off in advance through degasification wells. Closed mines keep leaking abandoned mine methane through vents, boreholes and cracks (EPA CMOP). Surface mines emit less, although very large ones can still release a lot.

Chart

Global methane from energy, by source

Million tonnes of methane, 2024 estimates

0 Mt12 Mt24 Mt36 Mt48 MtOil operations45 MtCoal40 MtNatural gas operations35 MtBioenergy (incompletecombustion)18 MtSource: IEA, Global Methane Tracker 2025.
0 Mt12 Mt24 Mt36 Mt48 MtOil operations45 MtCoal40 MtNatural gas operations35 MtBioenergy (incomplete combustion)18 MtSource: IEA, Global Methane Tracker 2025.
Coal mines release about as much methane as oil operations, and more than gas operations.

Globally, the International Energy Agency estimates that coal accounted for more than 40 million tonnes of methane in 2024, including over 4 Mt from abandoned mines, roughly the same order as oil operations (about 45 Mt) and natural gas operations (nearly 35 Mt) (IEA Global Methane Tracker 2025). For underground coal mines, the IEA notes that ventilation systems are usually the leading source. Mines that measure this gas can report it in a carbon footprint and look at capture, flaring or ventilation air methane oxidisers.

Dust is the other air problem. Cutting and blasting hard rock releases respirable crystalline silica, which causes silicosis. A U.S. Mine Safety and Health Administration final rule published in April 2024 set a permissible exposure limit of 50 micrograms per cubic metre over an 8-hour shift for all mines, with an action level of 25 ยตg/m3 (Federal Register, 2024). Diesel exhaust from loaders and trucks adds particulates, which is one reason many mines are moving toward battery-electric equipment and tighter fleet management.

Waste rock, tailings and energy use

Underground mines move far less overburden than open pits, which is their main environmental advantage. They still create waste: development rock from shafts and tunnels, and tailings, the finely ground rock left after the ore is processed. Both are stored at the surface unless they go back underground as backfill. Cemented paste backfill, which mixes tailings with a small share of binder, reduces the surface footprint and supports mined-out stopes, but needs a plant, binder and power.

Energy use per tonne is higher underground because the mine must hoist rock, pump water and run ventilation fans around the clock. That raises emissions where the power comes from fossil fuels, and it raises operating costs, which feeds into the next disadvantage.

Worker safety and cost disadvantages

Underground crews work under hazards that open pits do not have: roof and rib falls, gas ignition, fires in confined workings, inrushes of water and limited escape routes. Ground support, gas detection, refuge chambers and self-rescuers reduce the risk but add cost. Our guide to mine safety innovations covers the technology side.

Chart

Coal mined per employee hour, U.S.

Short tons per employee hour, 2023 and 2024

2023202402.557.510Underground3.43.2Surface9.78.9Source: EIA, Annual Coal Report 2024, Table 21.
2023202402.557.510Underground3.43.2Surface9.78.9Source: EIA, Annual Coal Report 2024, Table 21.
Surface mines move nearly three times as much coal per worker hour as underground mines, in both years.

Productivity shows the cost gap. In 2024 U.S. underground coal mines produced 3.24 short tons per employee hour against 8.94 at surface mines, and they employed 27,626 people against 16,303 at surface mines while producing less coal (EIA Annual Coal Report 2024, Table 21). The EIA states plainly that most U.S. coal comes from surface mines because surface mining is less expensive (EIA). Underground projects make sense where the deposit is too deep for a pit or where grade is high enough to pay for the extra cost.

Subsurface mining pros and cons compared with surface mining

Neither method is simply cleaner. Underground mining disturbs far less land at the surface and leaves smaller waste dumps, but it brings subsidence, gas and higher risk to workers. Surface mining is cheaper and safer per tonne but removes whole landscapes. The split in U.S. coal output shows how the two are used: in 2024 the country mined 512.5 million short tons of coal, of which 206.2 million came from underground mines, about 40% (EIA Annual Coal Report 2024, Table 1). Longwall mines produced 112.8 million tons of that underground total and continuous mining 92.8 million (EIA, Table 3).

Chart

U.S. coal production by mining method

Million short tons, 2024

0.0100.0200.0300.0400.0306.4Surface112.8Longwall92.8ContinuousSource: EIA, Annual Coal Report 2024, Tables 1 and 3.
0.0100.0200.0300.0400.0306.4Surface112.8Longwall92.8ContinuousSource: EIA, Annual Coal Report 2024, Tables 1 and 3.
Surface mines produced about 60% of U.S. coal; longwall led underground output.
Factor Underground (subsurface) mining Surface mining
Land disturbed at surface Small footprint around shafts, plant and dumps Whole pit or strip area plus waste dumps
Subsidence Main land risk, can extend beyond the panel edges Not a major issue; pit walls and dumps need stability instead
Groundwater Dewatering and flooding after closure; acid drainage from workings Dewatering of pits; acid drainage from exposed waste and pit lakes
Methane (coal) Vast majority of coal mine methane (EPA) Lower per mine
Worker productivity (U.S. coal, 2024) 3.24 short tons per employee hour 8.94 short tons per employee hour
Typical depth (U.S. coal guide) Over about 200 feet Under about 200 feet
Restoration Shafts sealed; subsidence repaired; water treated Whole area backfilled, re-soiled and replanted

For readers screening real sites, our US mining map by state shows where active underground and surface operations sit.

How does surface mining affect the environment differently?

Surface mining removes the topsoil and overburden to expose the deposit, so the first impact is total loss of vegetation and habitat over the pit and dump area. Mountaintop removal, a form of surface coal mining, removes the tops of mountains to reach seams (EIA). The waste rock is often placed in nearby valleys, which can bury headwater streams. Dust from blasting and haul roads travels further than underground dust, and open pits can leave pit lakes after closure.

U.S. law requires that dust and water runoff from coal mining be controlled and that mined land be reclaimed close to its original condition (EIA, Coal and the environment). Reclaimed surface mines can return to pasture, forest or other uses, which is harder to achieve when underground voids keep moving for years. So the honest comparison is this: surface mining causes larger visible damage that can be restored in place, and underground mining causes smaller visible damage with longer, harder-to-see effects in the rock and water below.

Strip mining pros and cons, for comparison with underground methods

โ–ถ Strip mining pros and cons, for comparison with underground methods ยท 4:37

What happens when a mine moves from underground to surface mining

Some old underground mines are later reopened as open pits, often because higher prices or bigger equipment make the remaining lower-grade rock worth mining in bulk. The consequences run both ways:

  • More land is disturbed: the pit and its dumps take over ground that the underground mine left in place.
  • Old voids become hazards: abandoned stopes and tunnels can collapse under heavy equipment, so they must be mapped, filled or blasted closed.
  • Legacy pollution can be removed or exposed: mining out old workings can remove sources of acid drainage, or it can expose more sulfide rock to air and rain.
  • Water changes: flooded workings may need pumping again, and the final pit may become a lake.
  • Safety and cost often improve: surface mining usually needs fewer workers per tonne, as the EIA productivity data above show.

The reverse move, from open pit to underground, happens when a pit gets too deep and the strip ratio (tonnes of waste per tonne of ore) becomes too high. Then the pit stops growing, but subsidence, ventilation and dewatering risks start.

How to reduce the environmental impact of underground mining

The controls that work are mostly decided at the design stage, before the first panel is cut:

Infographic

Reducing underground mining impacts in 5 steps

  1. 1BaselineMeasure ground levels, streams and water before mining.
  2. 2DesignSize panels and pillars to limit subsidence.
  3. 3Test rockCheck waste and tailings for acid potential.
  4. 4Capture gasDrain and use or flare methane.
  5. 5CloseBackfill, seal shafts, fund water treatment.
  1. Collect baselines: surface levels, stream flows, groundwater levels and water chemistry before mining, so later change can be measured.
  2. Design for subsidence: choose panel widths, pillar sizes and extraction heights that keep movement within agreed limits under sensitive features.
  3. Test rock for acid potential: sample waste rock and tailings for sulfide and carbonate content, and plan how acid-forming material will be stored or backfilled.
  4. Capture gas: drain methane before mining where possible and use or flare it instead of venting.
  5. Backfill and close properly: return waste underground where practical, seal shafts, and fund long-term water treatment if needed.

Each step needs data that can be repeated over time. Traceable records also help operators prove where material came from, the same idea behind product traceability systems.

What consultants should check on an underground project

A consultant reviewing an underground mine or licence will usually want to see:

  • A subsidence prediction with the area of influence drawn on a map, and a list of structures, streams and wells inside it.
  • Pre-mining groundwater levels and chemistry, with a monitoring plan that continues after closure.
  • Acid-base accounting results for waste rock and tailings.
  • Measured methane emissions (for coal) and the plan to capture or reduce them.
  • Dust and silica monitoring records against the applicable exposure limit.
  • A closure plan with costed water treatment and subsidence repair.

Satellite imagery helps with the surface part of this list: repeat images show new cracks, ponding, dying vegetation above panels and the growth of waste dumps, and they can screen a licence area before any field visit. Farmonaut’s mining platform maps project areas from Sentinel-2 and other satellite data; it supports exploration and site screening and is not a substitute for subsidence surveys or water sampling.

Remote sensing for mining explained without jargon

โ–ถ Remote sensing for mining explained without jargon ยท 2:01

Frequently asked questions

What are the main environmental impacts of subsurface mining?

Ground subsidence, lowered and polluted groundwater including acid mine drainage, methane and dust released through ventilation, and waste rock and tailings stored at the surface. Energy use per tonne is also higher than in open pits.

What are the disadvantages of subsurface mining?

Besides the environmental impacts, underground mining costs more per tonne, needs more workers per tonne (3.24 short tons per employee hour in U.S. underground coal mines in 2024 against 8.94 at surface mines, EIA) and carries risks of roof falls, gas explosions, fires and flooding.

Is surface mining more ecologically damaging than subsurface mining?

Per site, usually yes at the surface: an open pit removes all vegetation and soil over a large area. Underground mining disturbs less land but causes subsidence, groundwater changes and most coal mine methane. Which is worse depends on the deposit, the setting and how well each is managed and reclaimed.

What are the pros and cons of subsurface mining?

Pros: small surface footprint, little overburden to move, access to deep and high-grade deposits, and less visual and noise impact. Cons: subsidence, water disturbance, methane and dust, higher cost, lower productivity and greater worker risk.

How does subsidence from underground mining happen?

When rock is removed, the layers above sag or collapse into the void. With longwall and caving methods the collapse is planned and travels up to the surface; with room-and-pillar mining it can happen later if pillars fail.

How far can the ground sink above a longwall mine?

It depends on the extracted thickness, depth and rock. Above the multi-level Newstan Colliery in New South Wales the surface dropped by as much as five metres in places. Single-seam mines usually see less.

Why does underground mining cause acid mine drainage?

Mining lets air and water reach sulfide minerals such as pyrite. They react to form sulfuric acid, which dissolves metals from the rock. The EPA lists acid drainage as the most common water problem at abandoned mines.

How much methane comes from coal mines?

The IEA estimates more than 40 million tonnes worldwide in 2024, including over 4 Mt from abandoned mines. In the United States, active and abandoned coal mines produced about 7% of methane emissions in 2021 (EIA).

What happens when a mine switches from underground to surface mining?

More land is disturbed, old tunnels must be filled or blasted, legacy acid sources may be removed or exposed, and productivity per worker usually rises.

How deep does a mine need to be to go underground?

There is no single cut-off. For U.S. coal, the EIA says surface mining is usually used when coal is less than 200 feet deep and underground mining when it is deeper; for metals the choice depends on grade, orebody shape and the strip ratio.

More from Farmonaut: agro admin app, crop loan and insurance.

This page is general information, not engineering, legal or environmental advice. Subsidence, water and emissions limits differ by country and state; confirm requirements with the regulator and a qualified engineer for your site.

Authored by: Farmonaut Research & Content Team

Reviewed and verified by: Farmonaut Mining & Mineral Exploration Team

Reviewed November 2026 against the EIA Annual Coal Report 2024, EPA Coal Mine Methane Outreach Program, IEA Global Methane Tracker 2025 and 30 CFR Part 817.

Farmonaut mining

Map your mining site from space

Consultants use satellite maps to screen a licence area and track surface change around a mine before and during field work.

Farmonaut Mining Pro 3D Target View (Sample, Synthetic Data)

Mining Pro sample view, synthetic data

Sources

  1. EIA, Coal and the environment: eia.gov
  2. EIA, Mining and transportation of coal: eia.gov
  3. EIA, Annual Coal Report 2024, Table 1: Coal production and number of mines by state and mine type: eia.gov
  4. EIA, Annual Coal Report 2024, Table 3: Underground coal production by mining method: eia.gov
  5. EIA, Annual Coal Report 2024, Table 21: Coal productivity by state and mine type: eia.gov
  6. U.S. EPA, Coal Mine Methane Outreach Program, Frequent questions: epa.gov
  7. U.S. EPA, Abandoned Mine Drainage: epa.gov
  8. IEA, Global Methane Tracker 2025: Understanding methane emissions: iea.org
  9. eCFR, 30 CFR Part 817, performance standards for underground mining activities: ecfr.gov
  10. Subsidence Advisory NSW, NSW Government: subsidenceadvisory.nsw.gov.au
  11. Federal Register, MSHA final rule on respirable crystalline silica (18 April 2024): federalregister.gov
  12. EARTH Magazine, Acid mine drainage: the toxic legacy of gold mining in South Africa (2012): earthmagazine.org
  13. Longwall mining (overview with cited cases): en.wikipedia.org
  14. Acid mine drainage (overview): en.wikipedia.org



Discussion

Questions, corrections or field experience? Share them below. First-time comments are reviewed before they appear, and your email is never published.

No comments yet. Be the first to add a question or your experience.

Leave a comment

Farmonaut Farmonaut Trusted by 200,000+ users and 100+ businesses 200,000+ users trust us Get started