Fruit trees ยท Species comparison
Guava Tree Guide: Chilean vs Strawberry Guava, Guamuchil
Common guava grows to about 10 m, can fruit 2 to 4 years from seed and takes only a few degrees of frost (Morton, 1987). Strawberry and Chilean guava are rated hardier, but strawberry guava is a serious invader. Guamuchil is a separate legume tree.

Key takeaways
- Common guava suits frost-rare sites: it tolerates soil pH 4.5 to 9.4 but only a few degrees of frost (Morton, 1987).
- Raw common guava has 228.3 mg of vitamin C per 100 g; raw strawberry guava has 37 mg (USDA FoodData Central).
- Strawberry guava is a Category 1 invasive in Florida (University of Florida) and is described as the worst plant pest in Hawaii (IUCN database).
- Chilean guava is a low shrub rated RHS H4 (-10 to -5ยฐC), and it remains a niche berry crop.
- Guamuchil forms nitrogen-fixing nodules, but no measured fixation rate has been reported (World Agroforestry), so do not assume a fertilizer credit.
In this article
- Guava tree or alternative: which suits your land?
- Guava tree: size, climate and soil
- Guava crop yield, harvest and handling
- Guava nutrition: what the numbers show
- Strawberry guava: hardier, but a serious invader
- Chilean guava: a cool-climate niche berry
- Guamuchil: benefits and limits of a thorny legume
- Using these trees in a mixed farm
- Could a guava planting pay? Test your numbers
- FAQ
A guava tree (Psidium guajava) is a small evergreen fruit tree that grows to about 10 m and can start fruiting 2 to 4 years from seed, according to Julia Morton’s Fruits of Warm Climates. It takes only a few degrees of frost. Strawberry guava and Chilean guava are rated hardier but bear far smaller fruit, and guamuchil is not a guava at all: it is a thorny legume grown for pods, fodder and hedges.
This guide compares the four plants side by side for growers and land managers. It covers climate limits, height, fruit use, vitamin C and invasion risk, and it includes a calculator to test whether a small planting could pay for itself.
Guava tree or alternative: which suits your land?
Start with your coldest night, then ask what you want to sell or use. The table sums up the choice. Each plant has its own section below with the sources.
| Plant | Family | Cold limit | Main use | Main risk |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Common guava | Myrtle | A few degrees of frost | Fresh fruit, paste, juice | Fragile fruit, spreads in pasture |
| Strawberry guava | Myrtle | Red type about -5.6ยฐC | Small fruit, hedge, jelly | Serious invader in wet forest |
| Chilean guava | Myrtle | RHS H4 (-10 to -5ยฐC) | Niche berries, garden shrub | Hand picking, disease in damp sites |
| Guamuchil | Legume | Frost-sensitive | Pods, fodder, thorny hedge | Thorns, suckers, spread |
The table gives a first filter only. Local climate, soil and rules decide the final choice, so check with your extension service before you plant more than a few trees.
Chart
Upper plant height by species
Metres, upper figure of the usual range given in each source
Guava tree: size, climate and soil
Common guava is believed to come from an area running from southern Mexico into or through Central America, according to the same Morton chapter on guava. It reached southern Florida in about 1847 and is now grown in warm parts of the Americas, Asia, Africa and the Pacific islands.
The guava plant has smooth, copper-coloured bark that flakes away, and leathery leaves that smell when crushed. Trees live 30 to 40 years, but Morton notes that output declines after about the 15th year. Hard pruning can bring an old orchard back into bearing.
Climate
Guava grows in both humid and dry climates. Morton gives a rainfall range of 1,000 to 2,000 mm a year. Young trees have been damaged or killed in cold spells in California and Florida. Older trees killed to the ground have sent up new shoots that fruited two years later. That makes guava a crop for frost-rare sites.
Soil and salt
Soil is rarely the limit. Morton lists heavy clay, marl, light sand, gravel and limestone, and a pH range of 4.5 to 9.4. Good drainage is still the advice. The FAO crop salt tolerance table rates guava as moderately tolerant, with shoot and root growth starting to fall at a soil salinity of 4.7 dS/m. That figure comes from a growth study, not a fruit yield trial, so treat it as a guide.
Spacing, water and feeding
- Spacing: Morton suggests at least 10 m between trees, or 5 m if hedged. Hedged trees give less fruit each, but more per hectare.
- Water: trees survive drought, but fruit stays small if the crop goes short of water while it develops.
- Feeding: young trees respond to regular small doses of a complete fertilizer. Test your soil, and follow the product label and local rules.
- Thinning: heavy crops can break branches. Thinning protects the tree and gives larger fruit.
Guava crop yield, harvest and handling
Fruit matures 90 to 150 days after flowering. Some warm sites get two crops a year, and the crops can differ in size and quality. In southern Puerto Rico, the Morton chapter reports a heavy late-summer crop of small fruit and a lighter late-winter crop of larger fruit.
Chart
World output of three minor tropical fruits
Selected fruits, million tonnes a year, average 2015-2017 (FAO estimate)
Yield depends heavily on the cultivar and on how the orchard is managed. Morton reports counts of about 100 to 450 fruits per tree per crop in one long-established growing area. Use your own trial data or local extension figures before you plan income. Treat any single “kg per tree” figure with care unless it names the cultivar, tree age and site.
Handling is the hard part. Ripe guavas bruise easily and spoil fast. Morton describes cold storage at 8 to 10ยฐC and 85 to 95% relative humidity keeping unwrapped fruit of one cultivar, just turned yellow, in good condition for about 4 weeks. Growers without a cold chain or a processor nearby should plan for short routes to market.
Pests and diseases to watch
In Florida, Morton lists green shield scale, guava whitefly and a weevil that bores into new fruit. Anthracnose can attack fruit in wet seasons, and Fusarium wilt can enter through tunnels bored by beetle larvae. Scout often, and ask your extension service about current products. Always check the label and local rules before you spray.
โถ How to identify common plant health problems in the field, useful when you scout an orchard. ยท 19:39
Guava nutrition: what the numbers show
Guava’s best-known strength is vitamin C. The USDA FoodData Central entry for raw common guava lists 228.3 mg per 100 g, along with 5.4 g of fibre and 417 mg of potassium. The same database lists raw strawberry guava at 37 mg of vitamin C per 100 g, so the two fruits are not interchangeable on this measure.
A single lab number hides a wide spread. Morton reports 56 to 600 mg per 100 g for common guava. Vitamin C sits mainly in the skin and firm flesh and falls as fruit turns fully soft. Heat processing destroys about half of it. For a seller, that matters: a nutrition claim on a label should come from a test of your own product, not from a general table.
Guamuchil pods can also be rich. A 2025 study in Frontiers in Nutrition measured 122 to 139 mg of vitamin C per 100 g across the Manila tamarind accessions it tested. That is one study of 15 accessions from one district, so it does not set a standard for all guamuchil fruit.
None of this is medical advice. Traditional uses of leaves, bark and pods are recorded in older sources, but people with a health condition should speak to a doctor rather than rely on them.
Chart
Reported vitamin C ranges
mg per 100 g of fruit or pods, lowest and highest figure in each source
Strawberry guava: hardier, but a serious invader
Strawberry guava (Psidium cattleianum), also called Cattley guava, is believed to come from the lowlands of eastern Brazil. Morton’s chapter on the Cattley guava gives a height of 2 to 4 m, with the yellow-fruited form reaching up to 12 m. The red form can survive about -5.6ยฐC and handles poor and limestone soils. It has shallow roots but is fairly tolerant of drought.
The fruit is 2.5 to 4 cm long, with a spicy, strawberry-like taste and hard seeds. It lasts only 3 to 4 days at room temperature once fully ripe, so most goes to local processors. On good irrigated soil, Morton reports 30 tons from 2 ha. It is grown more as a hedge than as a fruit crop.
Check the rules before planting
Strawberry guava is sometimes sold as a quick windbreak, but that use needs a strong caveat. The University of Florida’s plant directory lists it as a FISC Category 1 invasive that invades forests and open woodlands in Florida. It has also been shown to reduce freshwater recharge in invaded Hawaiian forests.
The IUCN Global Invasive Species Database account calls it the worst plant pest in Hawaii and describes thickets that shade out native plants. A USDA NRCS fact sheet for the Pacific Islands adds that birds, pigs and cattle spread its seeds and that plants sucker readily.
- Hawaii and Florida: do not use it as a farm hedge. Choose a non-invasive windbreak.
- Other warm, wet regions: check your state, province or national weed list first.
- Already on your land: pull small plants and ask your local weed officer about larger stands. If you use a herbicide, follow the label and local rules.
โถ A tutorial on viewing crop health maps from satellite data in the web system. ยท 8:43
Chilean guava: a cool-climate niche berry
Chilean guava (Ugni molinae), called murtilla or murta in Chile, is a different genus from true guava. The RHS plant profile for Chilean guava describes a bushy evergreen shrub of 1 to 1.5 m with edible, aromatic, dark red berries about 1 cm across. It is native to Chile and Argentina. The RHS rates it H4, meaning hardy through most of the UK at -10 to -5ยฐC. Its growing advice is more careful: outdoors in mild areas, where it tolerates a few degrees of frost if sheltered from cold, drying winds, and in a cool greenhouse otherwise.
Chilean guava vs strawberry guava
These two are often confused because both have small red fruit with a strawberry note. The practical differences are simple.
- Size of plant: Chilean guava is a low shrub. Strawberry guava is a large shrub or small tree.
- Fruit: Chilean guava berries are about 1 cm across. Strawberry guava fruit is 2.5 to 4 cm.
- Climate: Chilean guava suits cool, moist, coastal places. Strawberry guava suits warm subtropical sites.
- Risk: strawberry guava has a well-documented invasive record in Hawaii and Florida. Check local lists for either plant.
Commercial growing
Commercial murtilla is still small. A US plant patent for the South Pearl-INIA selection, assigned to Chile’s agricultural research institute, says harvests came from wild plants until a domestication project began in 1996. It lists a yield of 1,142 g per plant for that selection.
A 2026 trade guide from Portal Frutรญcola says well-run orchards of the two INIA selections can pass 9.5 t/ha once production stabilises, with a rough break-even of 2 to 3 t/ha. It estimates set-up costs of 12.6 to 24.6 million Chilean pesos per hectare and calls its own figures inferred, so check them against local quotes. The same guide warns that disease in humid sites and hand picking are the main bottlenecks, and that this is a niche market. It also advises against sites with frequent frost, and it names frost during budbreak and flowering as a main climate risk. It also advises against sites with frequent frost, and it names frost during budbreak and flowering as a main climate risk.
Guamuchil: benefits and limits of a thorny legume
Guamuchil (Pithecellobium dulce), also known as Manila tamarind or blackbead tree, belongs to the legume family. It is native to the Americas, from the US and Mexico south into South America. The tree commonly reaches 10 to 15 m with a broad crown, and it bears coiled pods of 10 to 15 cm holding sweet white or red pulp.
The World Agroforestry species profile records these uses and traits:
- Food: the pulp is eaten fresh or roasted or made into a drink. Pods are sold at roadside stands in Mexico and Cuba.
- Fodder: livestock eat the pods and the leaves from hedge clippings. Feedipedia carries a feed table for the pods.
- Hedges: regular trimming makes a thorny hedge that keeps livestock out.
- Poor land: it grows on poor soils and tolerates drought and salty soil.
- Bees: flowers are visited by bees and give good honey.
Does guamuchil fix nitrogen?
It forms root nodules with Rhizobium bacteria, and nodules are common across soil types. But the same profile notes that no quantitative data on fixation have been reported. So do not cut your fertilizer plan on the assumption of a set nitrogen credit. Test the soil and adjust from the results.
Limits to weigh
The tree is frost-susceptible, so it belongs in warm, frost-rare areas. It suckers when roots are damaged, and thorns make handling and lopping harder. The wood is strong, but its crooked growth limits timber use, and it is a smoky fuel. The World Agroforestry profile also reminds planters that some trees are invasive and that local biosafety rules apply, so check before you plant.
Using these trees in a mixed farm
These trees can fit a mixed farm, but be wary of species scores and soil-gain percentages that name no study. The ideas below are design choices to test at small scale, not measured results.
- Match the plant to the frost map. Use your coldest recorded night, not the average winter.
- Keep orchard blocks simple. Guava needs light and harvest access, so leave wide alleys if you grow annual crops between young trees.
- Use guamuchil as a boundary hedge in frost-rare areas, and trim it often so that it stays dense and pods stay within reach.
- Skip invasive windbreaks. A short-term shelter gain does not justify a long-term weed problem.
- Plan the sale first. Soft fruit needs a buyer, a processor or a cold room before the first harvest.
- Keep records. Log yield per tree, grade-outs and labour hours, so that the next planting decision uses your own numbers.
Carbon claims need similar care. Trees do store carbon, but payment depends on a programme’s rules, its measurement method and a buyer. Read the contract and get professional advice before you count on that income.
On larger blocks, Farmonaut Satellite + AI Farm Monitoring System can show satellite vegetation maps for each field through the season, which can help you decide where to scout first. It does not replace walking the rows or checking fruit.
โถ An overview of carbon farming and how it relates to soil health, for readers weighing carbon income. ยท 5:30
Could a guava planting pay? Test your numbers
Before you buy trees, run a simple budget. The calculator below takes your planting density, fruit per tree, marketable share, price and yearly costs. Its starting values are round examples set close to break-even, not benchmarks. Replace each one with local figures, and get financial advice before a large investment.
Try the numbers for your own farm below.
Calculator
Guava planting budget per hectare
Enter your own planting density, yield, price and costs.
- Fruit you can sell: 2,800 kg/ha
- Sales: 7,000 US$/ha
- Break-even price: $2.43 per kg
Example values only, set near break-even; they are not benchmarks or forecasts. Every number is your input, and the page uses no hidden constants. Price is an example, use today’s price. Add set-up costs and years without a crop to your own long-term budget.
FAQ
How long does a guava tree take to fruit?
Morton reports fruiting 2 to 4 years from seed. Fruit then matures 90 to 150 days after flowering.
Can guava trees grow in cold climates?
Common guava survives only a few degrees of frost, and young trees are the most exposed. In colder regions, use a greenhouse or container, or grow a hardier plant such as Chilean guava where it suits the site.
Is strawberry guava invasive?
Yes, in several regions. The University of Florida lists it as a Category 1 invasive in Florida, and the IUCN database describes severe harm in Hawaii. Check your local weed list before planting.
What is the difference between Chilean guava and strawberry guava?
Chilean guava (Ugni molinae) is a low, cool-climate shrub with berries of about 1 cm. Strawberry guava (Psidium cattleianum) is a taller subtropical plant with fruit of 2.5 to 4 cm and a well-documented invasive record.
What is guamuchil?
Guamuchil is Pithecellobium dulce, a thorny legume tree from the Americas. People eat the sweet pulp in its coiled pods, and livestock eat the pods and leaves. It is not a true guava and belongs to a different plant family.
What is the root system of a guava tree like?
Morton gives no root depth for common guava, but describes strawberry guava as shallow-rooted. If slope stability is your goal, get local advice before you choose a species.
Related pages on our site: home page, satellite crop monitoring, web map view, mobile apps, carbon footprint tracking, product traceability, fleet management, satellite data API and API developer docs.
Farmonaut crop monitoring
See your orchard from space
Draw your fields once and Farmonaut shows satellite vegetation maps for them through the season, on web, Android or iOS.

Sources
- Morton, J. (1987), Guava, Fruits of Warm Climates, via Purdue NewCROP: hort.purdue.edu
- Morton, J. (1987), Cattley Guava, Fruits of Warm Climates, via Purdue NewCROP: hort.purdue.edu
- USDA FoodData Central, Guavas, common, raw (FDC 173044): fdc.nal.usda.gov
- USDA FoodData Central, Guavas, strawberry, raw (FDC 173045): fdc.nal.usda.gov
- FAO, Food Outlook feature on minor tropical fruits (July 2018): fao.org
- FAO, Annex 1: Crop salt tolerance data: fao.org
- World Agroforestry, Agroforestry Database 4.0: Pithecellobium dulce (Orwa et al., 2009): worldagroforestry.org
- Frontiers in Nutrition (2025), Nutritional valorization of Manila tamarind accessions: frontiersin.org
- Feedipedia (INRAE, CIRAD, AFZ, FAO), Manila tamarind pods: feedipedia.org
- Royal Horticultural Society, Ugni molinae plant profile: rhs.org.uk
- University of Florida IFAS, Plant Directory: Psidium cattleianum: plant-directory.ifas.ufl.edu
- IUCN Global Invasive Species Database, Psidium cattleianum full account: iucngisd.org
- USDA NRCS Pacific Islands Area, Invasive Species Fact Sheet: Strawberry guava: hicattle.org
- US Plant Patent PP21225, Murtilla plant named South Pearl-INIA (2010): patents.google.com
- Portal Frutรญcola, guide to growing murtilla (2026): portalfruticola.com
Discussion
Questions, corrections or field experience? Share them below. First-time comments are reviewed before they appear, and your email is never published.
No comments yet. Be the first to add a question or your experience.




Exploration consultancy · South Africa · Gold
Licence holder · Niger · Gold
Licence holder · Nigeria · Gold + lithium
Client · Tanzania · Gold
Client · Somalia · Gold
Client · Oregon, USA · Gold
Client & affiliate partner · Ghana · Gold