Comment

Soil amendments ยท Comparison guide

Mushroom Compost vs Manure: Nutrients, Salt and Safety

Mushroom compost is spent, steam-pasteurized mushroom substrate: a soil conditioner with about 17 lb of slow nitrogen per ton (Teagasc). Manure gives more fast nitrogen, and raw manure on food crops needs a 90/120-day interval before harvest under USDA organic rules.

Authored by Farmonaut Research & Content Team
Reviewed and verified by Farmonaut Agricultural Experts Team
Updated 12 November 2026 ยท 13 min read
Sentinel-2 Satellite View Of Farmland Near West Grove, Chester County, Pennsylvania
Sentinel-2 view of Farmland near West Grove, Chester County, Pennsylvania. Contains modified Copernicus Sentinel data, processed in Google Earth Engine.

Key takeaways

  • Fresh mushroom compost has 1.4โ€“2.1% total nitrogen on a dry basis and a pH of 5.8โ€“7.7 (Penn State Extension).
  • Per ton as delivered, Irish samples in 2012 held about 17 lb N, close to beef manure at 14 lb and above dairy at 10 lb (Teagasc; SARE).
  • Phosphorus in mushroom compost fell from 2.5 to 1.5 kg per tonne between 2003 and 2012 (Teagasc).
  • Weathering for 16 months cut potassium from 1.93โ€“2.58% to 0.43% and sodium to 0.06%, so weathered material is safer for salt-sensitive plants (Penn State).
  • Pennsylvania grew about 74% of US Agaricus mushrooms in 2025-2026, which is where bulk supply is easiest to find (USDA NASS, August 2026).
In this article
  1. Mushroom compost vs manure at a glance
  2. What is mushroom compost?
  3. Nutrients in mushroom compost and manure
  4. Benefits of mushroom compost for soil
  5. Benefits and risks of manure
  6. Mushroom compost vs manure compost: which to use when
  7. What is mushroom compost good for beyond farms?
  8. Where mushroom compost comes from
  9. Compare the cost per pound of nitrogen
  10. Test the load before you spread it
  11. Storage and spreading in the UK, Europe and Australia
  12. How to use mushroom compost safely
  13. Mushroom farming and circular use on farms
  14. How we checked the numbers

Mushroom compost is the spent growing material left after a mushroom crop, and it is a gentler soil conditioner with far less fast-acting nitrogen than most animal manures, although per ton its total nutrients are similar to cattle manure. Penn State Extension lists fresh spent substrate at about 1.4โ€“2.1% total nitrogen on a dry-weight basis with a pH of 5.8โ€“7.7, while raw manure carries more ammonium nitrogen, more pathogens and, in the case of poultry, far more phosphate. In short: pick mushroom compost when you want structure and organic matter with a modest nutrient boost, and pick manure when you want nitrogen and can manage the timing and food-safety rules.

This guide compares the two side by side with lab numbers from Penn State Extension, Teagasc in Ireland and SARE, shows how the nutrient content of mushroom compost has changed, and gives a calculator to compare the cost of each per pound of nitrogen with your own local prices.

Mushroom compost vs manure at a glance

The table sums up the main differences. The numbers are averages; every load differs, so ask the seller for a recent analysis.

Feature Mushroom compost Manure (solid, as-is)
What it is Spent substrate after a mushroom crop, steam-pasteurized before it leaves the farm Animal dung mixed with bedding; raw, aged or composted
Total nitrogen About 17 lb per ton fresh (Teagasc, 2012 samples) 10 lb/ton dairy, 14 beef, 25 chicken (SARE)
Phosphate About 7 lb P2O5 per ton (Teagasc, 2012, converted) 6 lb/ton dairy, 9 beef, 25 chicken (SARE)
pH 5.8โ€“7.7 fresh, about 7.1 when weathered (Penn State) Varies with animal and bedding
Soluble salts Can be high when fresh Can be high, above all in poultry litter
Weed seeds Killed by the final steam pasteurization (Penn State) Present in raw manure unless hot-composted
Pathogen rules Steam-pasteurized; ask your certifier how it is classed Raw manure: 90/120-day interval before harvest under USDA organic rules
Main job Soil structure, mulch, potting mixes Nutrient supply for crops and pasture

What is mushroom compost?

Commercial button mushrooms (Agaricus) grow in a prepared substrate. Penn State Extension lists the common ingredients as wheat straw bedding containing horse manure, hay, corn cobs, cottonseed hulls, poultry manure, brewer’s grain, cottonseed meal, cocoa bean hulls and gypsum. A “casing” layer of peat moss and ground limestone goes on top. After harvest the grower pasteurizes the material with steam, which kills weed seeds, insects and mushroom disease organisms, then sells or gives away what is left.

The same material goes by several names: spent mushroom substrate (SMS), spent mushroom compost (SMC), mushroom soil and, in some shops, mushroom manure. They all mean the same thing. It is not pure manure, although manure is one ingredient before the mushroom crop.

Because the substrate was built to feed mushrooms, much of the easy nitrogen has already been used. What remains is a dark, crumbly material that is high in organic matter. Penn State puts volatile solids, a rough measure of organic matter, at 52โ€“72% of dry weight in fresh material.

Fresh vs weathered mushroom compost

Some sellers place fresh substrate in fields for at least one winter and market it as “weathered” mushroom soil. Penn State’s 16-month weathered sample had much less potassium (0.43% vs 1.93โ€“2.58%) and sodium (0.06% vs 0.21โ€“0.33%) than fresh material, so rain had washed out much of the salt. Calcium rose to 6.27% of dry weight.

Penn State advises avoiding fresh spent substrate around salt-sensitive plants and says material weathered for 6 months or longer can be used in all gardens and with most plants.

Chart

Weathered mushroom compost: what it contains

% of dry weight, sample weathered 16 months

0.00%2.00%4.00%6.00%8.00%6.27%Calcium2.72%Nitrogen0.88%Magnesium0.84%Phosphorus0.43%Potassium0.06%SodiumSource: Penn State Extension, Spent Mushroom Substrate, Table 1 (updated December 2025).
0.00%2.00%4.00%6.00%8.00%Calcium6.27%Nitrogen2.72%Magnesium0.88%Phosphorus0.84%Potassium0.43%Sodium0.06%Source: Penn State Extension, Spent Mushroom Substrate, Table1 (updated December 2025).
After weathering, calcium dominates and sodium and potassium are low.

Nutrients in mushroom compost and manure

Nutrient numbers are easy to misread because sources use different bases. Penn State reports percent of dry weight. Teagasc and SARE report pounds or kilograms per ton of material as delivered, wet. The comparisons below use the as-delivered basis because that is what you pay for and spread.

Chart

Nutrients in Irish spent mushroom compost, 2003 vs 2012

kg per tonne of fresh material, survey means

200320120.02.55.07.510.0Nitrogen (N)8.08.6Phosphorus (P)2.51.5Potassium (K)9.75.4Source: Teagasc Technology Update 6355, Spent mushroom compost nutrient content (2013).
200320120.02.55.07.510.0Nitrogen (N)8.08.6Phosphorus (P)2.51.5Potassium (K)9.75.4Source: Teagasc Technology Update 6355, Spent mushroom compostnutrient content (2013).
Phosphorus fell by about 40% and potassium also dropped, while nitrogen held steady.

In 2011 and 2012 Teagasc analysed spent mushroom compost from 23 and then 20 randomly chosen Irish mushroom farms. The 2012 samples averaged 36% dry matter, 8.6 kg nitrogen, 1.5 kg phosphorus and 5.4 kg potassium per tonne fresh. That converts to roughly 17 lb N, 7 lb P2O5 and 13 lb K2O per US ton.

The SARE book Building Soils for Better Crops gives approximate totals for solid manure: 10 lb N per ton for dairy, 14 for beef, 25 for chicken and 10 for swine. On paper, then, a ton of mushroom compost carries about as much total nitrogen as cattle manure. The difference is in how fast it becomes available.

Why the nitrogen acts differently

Penn State’s table shows that most nitrogen in fresh substrate is organic, with only 0.06โ€“0.24% as ammonium. Organic nitrogen must be broken down by soil microbes before plants can use it, so it is released slowly over months and years. Fresh manure holds a larger share of ammonium and urea, which plants can use quickly but which can also be lost to the air or leach.

The University of Maryland Extension describes mushroom compost as a soil amendment with an approximate 2.75-1.5-1.5 analysis and warns it may contain higher soluble salt levels than other composts. Treat it as a soil builder that adds some nutrients, not as a fertilizer you can rely on for a crop’s full need.

Phosphorus in modern mushroom compost has fallen

Teagasc found the phosphorus content fell from 2.5 kg/t in 2003 to 1.3 kg/t in 2011 and 1.5 kg/t in 2012, a drop of over 40%. The reasons it gives are less poultry manure in the starting mix (to reduce odour) and about 10% higher mushroom yields taking more out of the compost. Potassium also trended down, with high variation between loads. If your nutrient plan uses an old book value, you may under-supply phosphorus.

Chart

Total nitrogen per ton, as delivered

lb of total N per US ton of solid material; mushroom compost converted from kg per tonne fresh

06121925Chicken manure25Mushroom compost17Beef manure14Dairy manure10Swine manure10Source: Teagasc, Spent mushroom compost nutrient content (2013, 2012 samples); SARE, Building Soils for Better Crops, Table 12.1.
06121925Chicken manure25Mushroom compost17Beef manure14Dairy manure10Swine manure10Source: Teagasc, Spent mushroom compost nutrient content(2013, 2012 samples); SARE, Building Soils for Better Crops,Table 12.1.
Mushroom compost sits close to cattle manure on total nitrogen, but far more of it is in slow organic form.

Benefits of mushroom compost for soil

The main benefit is organic matter. Penn State says the material “primarily improves soil structure” and provides a few nutrients, and notes that companies making potting mixes for garden centers use it for that reason. More organic matter helps sandy soil hold water and helps clay soil drain and crumble.

  • Better structure: crumbly organic matter opens up heavy soil and binds loose sand.
  • Water holding: Penn State notes that a top layer on newly seeded lawns holds water while seeds germinate and keeps birds off the seed.
  • Calcium and a near-neutral pH: the casing lime and gypsum add calcium, which suits soils that are slightly acid.
  • Low weed and pest load: steam pasteurization at the end of the crop kills weed seeds and insects.
  • Low pesticide residue: Penn State says residues are generally hard to find, because organic matter binds them and pasteurization heat breaks them down.

For a deeper look at why soil carbon matters for yield and water, our video on soil organic carbon covers the basics.

Why soil organic carbon matters for soil structure, water and yields.

โ–ถ Why soil organic carbon matters for soil structure, water and yields. ยท 12:28

Benefits and risks of manure

Chicken manure is a much richer nutrient source per ton; cattle and swine manure carry similar or lower totals than mushroom compost but more of their nitrogen is fast-acting. Manure also returns calcium, magnesium, sulfur and micronutrients too. SARE notes that soils receiving regular manure rarely show zinc deficiency. SARE also stresses that manure analyses vary widely from farm to farm with feed, bedding and storage.

The risks are pathogens, weed seeds, odour and nutrient losses. Under the USDA National Organic Program rules (7 CFR 205.203), raw manure on food crops must be incorporated at least 120 days before harvest when the edible part touches the soil, and 90 days when it does not. Compost under those rules must start at a C:N ratio of 25:1 to 40:1 and hold 131โ€“170 ยฐF for 3 days in a vessel or static aerated pile, or for 15 days in a windrow turned at least five times.

The FDA’s Produce Safety Rule page says the agency is still studying the right interval for raw manure and does not object to growers following the same 90/120-day standard meanwhile. Check the label, your certifier and local rules before you spread either material on food crops.

How to monitor crop health on your fields with satellite images in the Farmonaut web app.

โ–ถ How to monitor crop health on your fields with satellite images in the Farmonaut web app. ยท 8:43

Mushroom compost vs manure compost: which to use when

Composted manure sits between the two. Composting kills many pathogens and weed seeds and makes manure easier to handle, but its nitrogen is still higher than mushroom compost for poultry-based products. Use this guide to choose.

  • Vegetable beds before planting: weathered mushroom compost or well-made manure compost, worked into the top few inches. Best for: improving structure without a big nitrogen spike.
  • Heavy feeders such as corn, squash or brassicas: manure or manure compost, backed by a soil test. Best for: supplying nitrogen in season.
  • New lawns and turf topdressing: mushroom compost. Best for: holding moisture over seed.
  • Acid-loving plants such as blueberries, rhododendrons and azaleas: avoid mushroom compost; its lime raises pH.
  • Seedlings and salt-sensitive plants: avoid fresh mushroom compost; use weathered material or leach it first.
  • Pasture and field crops: manure, spread to a nutrient plan. Mushroom compost works too where it is close and cheap.

For a wider ranking of garden composts and manures, see our guide to the best organic compost and manure for a vegetable garden.

What is mushroom compost good for beyond farms?

Landscapers use it as a mulch and as a soil conditioner in new beds. The UK’s Royal Horticultural Society notes it can often be bought cheaply in bulk as a soil conditioner or mulch, but that it often contains some peat, which the RHS no longer recommends for horticultural use. Penn State says spring and summer are the best times to use weathered material as a mulch.

Potting-mix makers use it to improve the structure of their mixes. Turf managers use it to topdress new seed. Some reclamation and erosion-control projects use it to rebuild organic matter on bare ground.

Where mushroom compost comes from

Supply follows mushroom farms. The USDA NASS Mushrooms report of August 2026 puts US Agaricus sales at 620 million pounds in 2025-2026, of which Pennsylvania grew 460 million pounds, about 74%. All US mushroom sales were worth $922 million that season, down 16% on the year before. That is why bulk mushroom soil is easy to find in southeastern Pennsylvania and nearby states, and harder to find far from growing regions.

Chart

US Agaricus mushroom sales volume

million pounds sold per season (July to June)

02004006008002023-242024-252025-26United States 620Pennsylvania 460Source: USDA NASS, Mushrooms report, August 2026.
02004006008002023-242024-252025-26United StatesPennsylvania620460Source: USDA NASS, Mushrooms report, August 2026.
Pennsylvania’s volume kept rising while the US total fell in 2025-2026.

In Canada, the UK, Ireland, the Netherlands and Australia, mushroom farms also sell or give spent compost to local farmers and landscape suppliers. Ireland’s Teagasc notes that the producer of the compost is generally not the end user; most is spread on livestock and tillage farms as an NPK source.

Mushroom compost near me: how to source it

  1. Search for mushroom farms within an hour’s drive; many sell direct by the truckload.
  2. Ask landscape suppliers and garden centers for “mushroom soil” or “spent mushroom compost” in bulk.
  3. Ask whether it is fresh or weathered, and for how long it aged.
  4. Ask for a recent analysis of nitrogen, salts (electrical conductivity) and pH.
  5. Check delivery cost; for bulky low-nutrient material, haulage often decides the price per ton.
  6. Ask whether the farm grows under organic certification if you need certified inputs.

Our separate page on buying mushroom compost in bulk and its pH covers sourcing in more detail.

Compare the cost per pound of nitrogen

Price per ton or per cubic yard hides the real comparison. A cheaper load with less nitrogen can cost more per pound of nutrient once hauled and spread. Enter your local delivered prices and the nitrogen figure from each seller’s analysis. Remember that only part of the organic nitrogen becomes available in the first year for either material.

Try the numbers for your own farm below.

Calculator

Which costs less per pound of nitrogen?

Enter delivered prices and the nitrogen figure from each seller’s analysis.

US$/ton

lb/ton

US$/ton

lb/ton

lb
$0mushroom compost minus manure, US$ per lb N (negative = compost cheaper)
  • Mushroom compost, US$ per lb N: $2
  • Manure, US$ per lb N: $2
  • Mushroom compost needed: 5.9 tons
  • Manure needed: 7.1 tons

Example values only, chosen so both options land near the same cost; they are not benchmarks or quotes. Example nitrogen figures are about 17 lb per ton for mushroom compost (Teagasc, 2012 samples) and 14 lb per ton for beef manure (SARE). Total N is used; only part becomes available to crops in year one. Prices: example, use today’s price.

Test the load before you spread it

Both materials vary from load to load, so a lab test pays for itself on any field-scale job. The Ontario agronomy guide for field crops says a manure analysis is preferable to table values because nutrient content changes with species, moisture, diet and storage losses. It recommends seasonal sampling where manure is stored outdoors.

The University of Nebraska-Lincoln manure guide recommends using the as-is values on your analysis report to work out nutrient availability. Dry-matter values help when you compare repeat samples over time, because moisture changes with storage and handling. The same logic applies to mushroom compost: a pile left out over winter loses salts and potassium and gains moisture.

  • Ask for: dry matter, total N, ammonium N, P2O5, K2O, pH and electrical conductivity (salts).
  • Sample well: take several small samples from different parts of the pile and mix them.
  • Repeat: test again when the supplier, the bedding or the storage changes.

Storage and spreading in the UK, Europe and Australia

Outside the US, organic manures fall under nutrient and water rules. In Ireland, the Good Agricultural Practice (Nitrates) regulations set standard nutrient values that farmers use in their plans; Teagasc found the phosphorus value assumed there for spent mushroom compost was higher than in modern samples. Farmers in the UK, EU, Canada and Australia face similar closed periods, buffer zones near water and nutrient limits for organic manures. Check local rules and your nutrient adviser before field application, and record each load in your nutrient plan.

For home gardeners the rules matter less, but the practical points are the same: store piles away from drains and streams, cover them in wet weather and spread when the soil is not waterlogged.

How to use mushroom compost safely

  1. Test your soil first. Know your pH, phosphorus and salt levels before you add any amendment.
  2. Prefer weathered material for gardens, or water fresh material well and let it drain before planting.
  3. Mix it in. Work 1โ€“3 inches into the top 6โ€“8 inches of soil rather than planting straight into a pure layer. Maryland Extension notes that mixing into the soil or watering before use reduces the risk of salt injury.
  4. Watch pH. Keep it away from blueberries and other acid-loving plants.
  5. Count its nutrients. Include its N, P and K in your nutrient plan so you do not over-apply manure or fertilizer on top.
  6. Keep piles off watercourses and cover stored material so rain does not wash nutrients away.

Mushroom farming and circular use on farms

Mushroom farms take in straw, manure and other farm by-products and return spent compost to the land. For farms near a grower, that loop can replace part of a bought fertilizer bill and add organic matter at the same time. Small growers who start oyster or shiitake production on logs, straw or sawdust produce a different spent substrate that is lower in manure-based nutrients; test it before treating it like button-mushroom compost.

Our video on small agriculture business ideas includes mushroom growing as one low-land option.

Once a field has received compost or manure, you can follow how the crop responds over the season. The Farmonaut Satellite + AI Farm Monitoring System shows vegetation index maps of each field from satellite images, so uneven growth after an amendment shows up early.

Related pages on our site: farm management dashboard, mobile and web apps, carbon footprinting, crop loan and insurance checks, satellite and weather API docs, API access, fleet management, product traceability.

Ten small agriculture business ideas, including mushroom growing.

โ–ถ Ten small agriculture business ideas, including mushroom growing. ยท 6:03

How we checked the numbers

Nutrient figures come from lab surveys, not from sellers. Penn State’s table reports fresh and weathered spent substrate as percent of dry weight. Teagasc reports kilograms per tonne of fresh material from random samples taken on Irish farms in 2003, 2011 and 2012. SARE gives approximate pounds per ton for solid manure from several sources. To compare like with like, we converted Teagasc’s metric values to pounds per US ton (1 kg per tonne equals 2 lb per ton) and phosphorus to phosphate (P x 2.29) and potassium to potash (K x 1.2). These are averages for comparison. Your own load will differ, so use a lab report for any nutrient plan, and treat the calculator results as a guide, not a quote.

FAQ

Is mushroom compost better than manure?

Neither is better for every job. Mushroom compost is better for soil structure, mulch and lawns, and carries a lower pathogen and weed load after pasteurization. Manure supplies more readily available nitrogen per ton, especially chicken manure (about 25 lb N per ton, SARE), but needs careful timing on food crops.

What is mushroom compost good for?

Improving soil structure, adding organic matter, mulching beds in spring and summer, topdressing new lawns and blending into potting mixes. Avoid it around acid-loving plants and use weathered material near salt-sensitive seedlings.

What is the difference between mushroom compost and regular compost?

Regular compost is made from yard waste, food scraps or manure. Mushroom compost was first prepared for a mushroom crop, then pasteurized after harvest. It contains lime and gypsum from the casing, so it is often more alkaline and saltier when fresh than garden compost.

Is mushroom compost the same as humus?

No. Humus is the stable, well-decomposed organic matter in soil. Mushroom compost is partly decomposed material that will keep breaking down in the soil and, over time, adds to the soil’s humus.

Can I use fresh mushroom compost in a vegetable garden?

Penn State advises against using fresh spent substrate around salt-sensitive vegetables. Let it weather for 6 months or longer, or water it well and mix it into the soil before planting. Check local rules if you sell produce.

How much mushroom compost should I add?

A common garden approach is 1โ€“3 inches mixed into the top 6โ€“8 inches of soil. Base field rates on a soil test and a nutrient plan, counting the compost’s nitrogen and phosphorus, and get advice from your local extension service.

Authored by: Farmonaut Research & Content Team

Reviewed and verified by: Farmonaut Agricultural Experts Team

Reviewed November 2026 against Penn State Extension’s spent mushroom substrate analysis, Teagasc’s 2013 nutrient survey, SARE’s manure tables, University of Maryland Extension, the USDA organic rules (7 CFR 205.203), FDA’s Produce Safety Rule page, the RHS and the USDA NASS Mushrooms report of August 2026.

Farmonaut crop monitoring

See how your fields respond

Map your fields once and Farmonaut shows satellite vegetation maps through the season, on web, Android or iOS.

Open The Farmonaut Crop Monitoring Web AppGet The Farmonaut App On Google PlayGet The Farmonaut App On The App Store
Farmonaut Web App With A Satellite Crop Health Map

Sources

  1. Penn State Extension, Spent Mushroom Substrate (updated December 2025): extension.psu.edu
  2. Teagasc, Spent mushroom compost: nutrient content for application to agricultural crops (Technology Update 6355, 2013): teagasc.ie
  3. SARE, Building Soils for Better Crops: Animal manures for increasing organic matter and supplying nutrients: sare.org
  4. University of Maryland Extension, Organic Matter and Soil Amendments: extension.umd.edu
  5. eCFR, 7 CFR Part 205, National Organic Program: ecfr.gov
  6. US FDA, FSMA Final Rule on Produce Safety: fda.gov
  7. Royal Horticultural Society, Mulches and mulching: rhs.org.uk
  8. USDA NASS, Mushrooms (August 2026): esmis.nal.usda.gov
  9. Ontario OMAFRA, Agronomy Guide for Field Crops, Chapter 9: Soil fertility and nutrient use (2022): ontario.ca
  10. University of Nebraska-Lincoln Extension, G1335 Manure nutrient management: extensionpubs.unl.edu


Discussion

Questions, corrections or field experience? Share them below. First-time comments are reviewed before they appear, and your email is never published.

No comments yet. Be the first to add a question or your experience.

Leave a comment

Farmonaut Farmonaut Trusted by 200,000+ users and 100+ businesses 200,000+ users trust us Get started