Comment

Gold ยท Field identification

Gold vs Pyrite Flakes: 7 Differences and a Weight Test

Gold dents, pyrite breaks. Gold streaks yellow, pyrite greenish black. And gold is about four times heavier: specific gravity 19.3 against roughly 5 (Webmineral, Geology.com).

Authored by Farmonaut Research & Content Team
Reviewed and verified by Farmonaut Mining & Mineral Exploration Team
Updated 12 November 2026 ยท 11 min read
Sentinel-2 Satellite View Of Bonanza Creek Placer District, Klondike, Yukon
Sentinel-2 true-colour composite of Bonanza Creek placer district, Klondike, Yukon (63.98ยฐN, 139.33ยฐW). Contains modified Copernicus Sentinel data, 2022 to 2026, processed in Google Earth Engine.

Key takeaways

  • The USGS names pyrite, chalcopyrite and weathered mica as the three common fool’s gold minerals.
  • Pin test: gold gouges like soft lead; pyrite and chalcopyrite powder or crumble (USGS).
  • Streak: gold golden yellow, pyrite and chalcopyrite greenish black, mica white (USGS).
  • Pure gold SG is 19.3 (natural gold 16 to 19.3); pyrite is 4.9 to 5.2 and mica about 2.8 to 3.1.
  • A 1 mm by 0.05 mm gold flake weighs about 0.76 mg, worth roughly US$0.10 at Kitco’s 5 November 2026 spot price.
In this article
  1. Gold vs pyrite flakes at a glance
  2. 7 key differences between placer gold flakes and pyrite flakes
  3. Pyrite flakes vs gold flakes: how much heavier is gold?
  4. Other flakes mistaken for gold: chalcopyrite and mica
  5. How to tell gold from pyrite in the field: step by step
  6. When a lab test is worth it
  7. What placer gold flakes mean for a claim
  8. What a gold flake is worth
  9. Frequently asked questions

The difference between gold and pyrite flakes comes down to three checks you can do in a minute: gold is soft and dents under a pin, pyrite is brittle and breaks; gold leaves a golden-yellow streak on unglazed porcelain, pyrite leaves a greenish-black one; and gold is about four times heavier for its size (specific gravity 19.3 for pure gold against 4.9 to 5.2 for pyrite, per Webmineral and Geology.com). The US Geological Survey names pyrite as the mineral most often mistaken for gold, followed by chalcopyrite and weathered mica.

This guide goes further than the usual list. It covers the seven differences in order of how reliable they are in a pan, adds the two other look-alikes that cause most false alarms in placer sand, shows how much a flake really weighs, and ends with a calculator that turns flake size into milligrams and US$ value.

Gold vs pyrite flakes at a glance

The table below puts the field properties side by side. Specific gravity (SG) is how many times heavier a mineral is than the same volume of water. Mohs hardness is a 1 to 10 scratch scale: a fingernail is about 2.5, a copper coin about 3.5 and a steel knife about 5.5.

Chart

Specific gravity of gold and its look-alikes

Times heavier than water; average or mid-range values

0.005.0010.0015.0020.00Gold (pure)19.30Magnetite5.15Pyrite5.05Chalcopyrite4.19Biotite3.09Muscovite2.82Source: Webmineral (gold, chalcopyrite, muscovite, biotite, magnetite); Geology.com (pyrite).
0.005.0010.0015.0020.00Gold (pure)19.30Magnetite5.15Pyrite5.05Chalcopyrite4.19Biotite3.09Muscovite2.82Source: Webmineral (gold, chalcopyrite, muscovite, biotite,magnetite); Geology.com (pyrite).
Gold is about four times denser than pyrite and six times denser than mica, which is why it stays in the pan.
Property Placer gold flake Pyrite flake or grain
Colour Butter to deep yellow; paler when silver-rich Pale brass yellow, often tarnished dull
Colour in shade Stays yellow from every angle Flashes bright, then looks dark or grey
Streak on porcelain Golden yellow Greenish black to brownish black
Mohs hardness 2.5 to 3 6 to 6.5
Response to a pin Dents, bends, flattens Snaps, crumbles or powders
Specific gravity 19.3 pure; natural gold 16 to 19.3 4.9 to 5.2
Shape Rounded, irregular, hammered edges Cubes, striated faces, sharp broken edges
Magnetism Non-magnetic Non-magnetic (unlike magnetite in black sand)
Nitric acid Insoluble Dissolves in concentrated acid

Sources: Webmineral data for gold; Geology.com for pyrite; Washington Division of Geology and Earth Resources for the acid behaviour.

7 key differences between placer gold flakes and pyrite flakes

Ranked from most to least reliable in the field. The first three settle almost every case; the rest back them up.

Pyrite meets real gold in the story of the Arkansas gold rush that wasn

โ–ถ Pyrite meets real gold in the story of the Arkansas gold rush that wasn’t ยท 6:31

Chart

Mohs hardness, top of each range

Scratch scale 1 to 10; a steel knife is about 5.5

0.01.83.55.27.02.5Muscovite3.0Gold3.0Biotite3.5Chalcopyrite6.5PyriteSource: Webmineral; Geology.com (pyrite).
0.01.83.55.27.02.5Muscovite3.0Gold3.0Biotite3.5Chalcopyrite6.5PyriteSource: Webmineral; Geology.com (pyrite).
Pyrite is harder than steel, so it chips; gold is soft enough to dent with a pin.

1. The pin test: gold dents, pyrite breaks

Press a steel pin or knife point on the flake. According to the USGS, fool’s gold minerals flake, powder or crumble when poked with a metal point, while gold gouges or indents like soft lead. This works on flakes too small to streak, and it does not destroy a gold flake; it just flattens it a little.

2. The pyrite vs gold streak test

A streak is the colour of a mineral’s powder. Rub the grain across the back of an unglazed bathroom tile or a porcelain streak plate. Gold leaves a golden-yellow line; pyrite and chalcopyrite leave a dark green to black line; common micas leave a white line (USGS). The streak test needs a grain large enough to hold, so in practice it is used on coarse flakes and pickers rather than fine colours.

3. Weight in the pan

Gold is the heaviest thing in a pan of river sand. Pure gold has an SG of 19.3 and natural gold, which carries silver, runs from about 16 to 19.3 (Webmineral). Pyrite is about 5. Pyrite does not float, and it will stay in a careless pan, but it washes forward long before gold does. If a flake rides out with the black sand when you tilt and swirl, it is not gold. The difference in mass is large: the chart below shows how a flake of the same size weighs about four times more in gold than in pyrite.

4. Colour that holds in the shade

Turn the pan out of direct sunlight. Gold keeps the same warm yellow from every angle because it reflects evenly. Pyrite and mica flash when the light hits a face and then go grey or dark as you tilt them. This is the quickest screen, but it is not proof: tarnished or iron-stained gold can look dull and coated, and fresh chalcopyrite can look convincingly golden.

5. Shape and edges

Placer gold has been hammered in a stream for a long time. It is rounded, folded and smooth, with no flat crystal faces. Washington’s state geologists note that pyrite commonly occurs as cubic crystals, while gold is almost always found in irregular shapes (Washington DNR, placer gold mining). Pyrite in sand is usually a grain, a cube fragment or a sharp chip, not a true flake, because it is too brittle to flatten. Under a 10x hand lens, look for striations (fine parallel lines) on pyrite faces.

6. Hardness

Gold sits at 2.5 to 3 on the Mohs scale; pyrite at 6 to 6.5, harder than a steel knife (Geology.com). If a grain scratches glass, it is not gold. Hardness and the pin test are related, but hardness explains why pyrite chips into angular pieces under a hammer while gold spreads into a thinner sheet.

7. Chemistry and stability

Gold does not tarnish or dissolve in single acids, and it stays bright in a stream bed for thousands of years. Pyrite is an iron sulfide (FeS2). It is soluble in concentrated nitric acid, and gold is not (Washington DNR). In air and water pyrite slowly oxidises to rust and sulfuric acid, which is why old sulfide tailings can produce acid mine drainage. For a prospector this means pyrite in old concentrates often looks rusty, while gold in the same jar looks the same as the day it was panned. Leave acid tests to a lab or an assayer; concentrated acids are dangerous to handle in the field.

Pyrite flakes vs gold flakes: how much heavier is gold?

Most panners judge weight by feel, but small flakes are too light to feel. Mass is volume times density, so it can be worked out. A thin flake 1 mm across and 0.05 mm thick has a volume of about 0.039 cubic millimetres. In pure gold that is about 0.76 mg; in pyrite it is about 0.20 mg. Washington’s geologists give a sense of scale: some flour gold is so fine that about 14 million colours are needed to weigh one troy ounce.

Chart

Flake mass by diameter

Milligrams for a round flake 0.05 mm thick; calculated from density

03.87.511.2150.5 mm1 mm2 mm3 mm4 mmGold 12.1Pyrite 3.1Source: Farmonaut calculation from Webmineral (gold SG 19.3) and Geology.com (pyrite SG about 5.0).
03.87.511.2150.5 mm1 mm2 mm3 mm4 mmGoldPyrite12.13.1Source: Farmonaut calculation from Webmineral (gold SG 19.3)and Geology.com (pyrite SG about 5.0).
At every size a gold flake weighs about four times as much as a pyrite flake of the same shape.

That density gap is also why gold collects where water slows: on bedrock, on the inside of bends and below rapids. The same Washington report notes that placer values are almost always concentrated on or near bedrock, or on a clay “false bedrock”. Pyrite, chalcopyrite and mica travel further downstream and settle in lighter layers. For more on where flakes end up in a profile, see our guide to how deep gold is found.

Other flakes mistaken for gold: chalcopyrite and mica

Many reports of “pyrite flakes” in a pan are really one of two other minerals. Knowing all three makes the decision faster.

Chalcopyrite

Chalcopyrite (CuFeS2) is the main ore of copper. It is brassier and often more golden than pyrite, sometimes with a green or iridescent tarnish. It is softer than pyrite at about 3.5, so it can be scratched by a knife, but it is still brittle and powders under a pin. Its streak is greenish black and its SG averages 4.19 (Webmineral). In a pan it behaves much like pyrite.

Weathered mica (biotite and muscovite)

Weathered biotite turns bronze or gold and forms thin, shiny flakes that look exactly like flake gold in moving water. The tell is weight and elasticity. Mica’s SG is only about 2.8 to 3.1 (Webmineral averages: muscovite 2.82, biotite 3.09), so it lifts off the pan with the lightest swirl. The Washington report adds that mica flakes are flexible but elastic, springing back when bent, while gold stays bent. Mica splits into layers with a knife tip and leaves a white streak.

Black sand minerals

Magnetite (SG about 5.15) and hematite stay with gold in the final concentrate, which is why the last stage of panning is slow. They are black, not yellow, but a magnet removes magnetite and makes any gold easier to see.

How to tell gold from pyrite in the field: step by step

A practical routine for a pan of concentrate, using only a pan, a magnet, a hand lens, a pin and a porcelain tile.

Infographic

Gold or not? Five checks

  1. 1ShadeDoes it stay yellow when tilted out of the sun?
  2. 2SwirlDoes it stay behind when black sand moves?
  3. 3LensRounded and folded, or cubic and layered?
  4. 4PinDents (gold), crumbles (sulfide) or springs back (mica)?
  5. 5StreakYellow (gold), greenish black (pyrite) or white (mica)?
  1. Pan down to black sand, then stop washing hard. Tilt the pan and swirl gently so the heaviest material stays in the corner.
  2. Move the pan into shade. Note any yellow grains that keep their colour as you tilt the pan.
  3. Run a magnet, inside a plastic bag, through the concentrate to remove magnetite.
  4. Look at the suspects under a 10x lens: rounded and folded edges point to gold; cubes, striations or layered sheets point to pyrite or mica.
  5. Press a pin on one suspect grain. Dents mean gold; crumbles mean a sulfide; springs back means mica.
  6. For a larger flake or picker, rub it on the porcelain tile and read the streak colour.
  7. Keep the confirmed gold in a vial with water and record where it came from (stream, depth, distance from bedrock). That record matters more than the flake if you are assessing ground.

Pan only where you have permission and follow local rules. In some states suction dredging and motorised equipment need a permit; see our guide to California gold panning laws as an example. Never use mercury to recover gold.

When a lab test is worth it

Field tests tell gold from pyrite reliably, but they do not tell you how much gold is in the ground or how pure it is. A consultant reviewing a placer claim, or a buyer looking at a property, needs numbers that hold up:

  • Fire assay of a bulk sample or concentrate gives grams of gold per tonne (g/t), the standard way to report grade.
  • Fineness is gold purity in parts per thousand. Placer gold is never pure; silver lowers its density and value, which is why natural gold’s SG range starts near 16.
  • Handheld XRF gives a quick surface reading of composition but should be confirmed by assay.
  • Gold in pyrite: in some hard-rock deposits pyrite carries microscopic gold worth mining (Geology.com). Brassy sulfide grains in a placer can point upstream to such a source, so a sulfide concentrate is sometimes worth assaying too.

Our page on the types of gold rocks and deposits explains how placer gold relates to the lode sources it erodes from.

How gold is mined and refined, from rock to ring

โ–ถ How gold is mined and refined, from rock to ring ยท 5:27

What placer gold flakes mean for a claim

A few confirmed flakes show that gold is present in a drainage. They do not show that a claim is worth working. Placer economics depend on grade (grams or milligrams of gold per cubic metre of gravel), volume of gravel, depth to bedrock, water and access. Most placer gold in the United States comes from Alaska and the Western States, with several large placer mines in Alaska and many smaller ones elsewhere, according to the USGS Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026. The same report estimates US mine output at 160 tonnes in 2025, with Nevada lode mines producing about 64% and Alaska about 22%.

Before buying or working ground, map where the old channels, terraces and bedrock highs are. Satellite imagery helps here: it shows historic workings, tailings and terraces across a whole drainage before anyone travels to sample it. Farmonaut offers satellite-based mineral detection for licence and claim areas; it is a screening tool ahead of field sampling, not a substitute for it. Project questions can go through the mining query form.

Can a satellite detect gold? What imagery really maps

โ–ถ Can a satellite detect gold? What imagery really maps ยท 2:00

What a gold flake is worth

Single flakes are worth little, which is why placer grade is measured over cubic metres of gravel. On 5 November 2026 Kitco reported spot gold near US$4,119.50 per troy ounce (Kitco). A troy ounce is 31.1035 grams, so a pure 0.76 mg flake holds about US$0.10 of gold at that price, before refining charges and before allowing for fineness. A flake 4 mm across and 0.05 mm thick, about 12 mg in pure gold, would be worth around US$1.60. Use the calculator below with today’s price and your own measurements.

Calculator

Gold flake weight and value

Measure a flake under a lens and enter its size.

mm

mm

%

US$/troy oz
0.8 mgmass if pure gold
  • Same flake in pyrite (mg): 0.2
  • Gold content value (US$): 0.1
  • Flakes this size per troy ounce: 41,039

Example values only. Treats the flake as a flat disc; real flakes are irregular. Natural gold fineness is often below 1,000; the price is an input, so use today’s spot price. Pyrite mass uses SG 5.0. Refining charges are not included.

Frequently asked questions

What is the quickest way to tell gold from pyrite?

Press it with a pin. Gold dents or bends like soft lead; pyrite crumbles or snaps. The USGS gives this as the main field test.

What colour streak does pyrite leave compared with gold?

Pyrite leaves a greenish-black to brownish-black streak on unglazed porcelain. Gold leaves a golden-yellow streak.

Do pyrite flakes float when panning?

No. Pyrite has an SG of about 5, so it sinks, but it washes out of a pan far sooner than gold at 16 to 19.3. Mica, at about 3, is what seems to float.

Can pyrite form flat flakes?

Rarely. Pyrite is brittle and usually breaks into cubes, grains and sharp chips. Thin golden flakes that are not gold are more often weathered mica.

Is fool’s gold always pyrite?

No. The USGS lists three common fool’s gold minerals: pyrite, chalcopyrite and weathered mica.

Why is placer gold sometimes pale?

Natural gold contains silver. The more silver, the paler the colour and the lower the density, down to about SG 16.

Does finding pyrite mean gold is nearby?

Not always, but pyrite and gold often form together in hydrothermal veins, and some pyrite carries microscopic gold. It is a reason to sample, not proof of gold.

Can a magnet separate gold from pyrite?

A magnet removes magnetite, not pyrite. Both gold and pyrite are non-magnetic, so separate them by weight, colour and the pin test.

Is pyrite harmful in soil or water?

Pyrite oxidises to sulfuric acid and iron oxide when exposed to air and water. In large volumes, such as mine waste, this can cause acid mine drainage.

How many gold flakes make an ounce?

It depends on size. Washington’s state geologists estimate about 14 million flour-gold colours per troy ounce; a 1 mm flake 0.05 mm thick is about 41,000 per ounce.

More from Farmonaut: contact us, placer gold flakes vs pyrite flakes 7 key differences.

This page is for information only. It is not investment or legal advice. Prospect only with the landowner’s permission and any licence or permit required, and never use mercury.

Authored by: Farmonaut Research & Content Team

Reviewed and verified by: Farmonaut Mining & Mineral Exploration Team

Reviewed November 2026 against USGS fool’s gold guidance, USGS Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026, Washington DNR placer guidance and Webmineral mineral data.

Farmonaut mining

Map your mining site from space

Consultants reviewing a placer claim can send the area as coordinates or KML for a satellite screen of old workings, terraces and drainage, ahead of field sampling.

Farmonaut Mining Pro 3D Target View (Sample, Synthetic Data)

Mining Pro sample view, synthetic data

Sources

  1. USGS, What is “Fool’s Gold?”: usgs.gov
  2. Geology.com, Pyrite: properties and uses: geology.com
  3. Washington Division of Geology and Earth Resources, Placer gold mining (Open File Report 79-0): dnr.wa.gov
  4. Webmineral, Gold mineral data: webmineral.com
  5. Webmineral, Chalcopyrite mineral data: webmineral.com
  6. Webmineral, Muscovite mineral data: webmineral.com
  7. Webmineral, Biotite mineral data: webmineral.com
  8. Webmineral, Magnetite mineral data: webmineral.com
  9. USGS, Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026: Gold: pubs.usgs.gov
  10. Kitco, gold price report, 5 November 2026: kitco.com
  11. EARTH Magazine, acid mine drainage and pyrite in South African gold fields: earthmagazine.org



Discussion

Questions, corrections or field experience? Share them below. First-time comments are reviewed before they appear, and your email is never published.

No comments yet. Be the first to add a question or your experience.

Leave a comment

Farmonaut Farmonaut Trusted by 200,000+ users and 100+ businesses 200,000+ users trust us Get started