Comment

Crop protection ยท Hopper control guide

Hopper Insecticide: Best Picks for Planthoppers

Brown planthoppers in China kept extremely high resistance to imidacloprid and buprofezin in 2020-2023, while triflumezopyrim resistance rose but stayed low, from 2.5 to 7.1-fold. How to count hoppers, when a spray pays, and how to rotate insecticide groups.

Authored by Farmonaut Research & Content Team
Reviewed and verified by Farmonaut Agricultural Experts Team
Updated 12 November 2026 ยท 14 min read
Sentinel-2 Satellite View Of Rice Fields On The Grand Prairie, Arkansas, Usa
Sentinel-2 view of Rice fields on the Grand Prairie, Arkansas, USA. Contains modified Copernicus Sentinel data, processed in Google Earth Engine.

Key takeaways

  • Chinese monitoring of brown planthopper in 2020-2023 found average resistance to triflumezopyrim rising from 2.5 to 7.1-fold and dinotefuran from 119.5 to 268.1-fold (Pesticide Biochemistry and Physiology, 2024).
  • A survey across South and East Asia found up to 220-fold resistance to imidacloprid and 223-fold to ethiprole (Pest Management Science, 2016).
  • Rotate IRAC mode-of-action groups between generations; products in the same group act on the same target.
  • Potato leafhopper thresholds in alfalfa fall as hay value rises: 0.37 to 0.13 per sweep for alfalfa under 4 inches at US$14/acre control (Iowa State).
  • Count first with a beat sheet or sweep net; in alfalfa, cutting early can replace a spray when harvest is within a week.
In this article
  1. Which hopper are you dealing with?
  2. Are planthoppers pests?
  3. How to scout hoppers with a beat sheet or sweep net
  4. When does a hopper spray pay?
  5. Best insecticide for brown planthopper
  6. Best insecticide for hoppers in North American crops
  7. Integrated hopper management
  8. Using satellite crop maps to target scouting
  9. Insecticide spray break-even calculator
  10. How we checked the numbers
  11. FAQ

The best hopper insecticide is the one your hoppers are not yet resistant to, applied only after a beat sheet or sweep net count passes your crop’s threshold. For brown planthopper in rice, field studies in East Asia show very high resistance to imidacloprid and buprofezin, while triflumezopyrim (IRAC group 4E) still showed low resistance in Chinese monitoring from 2020 to 2023. For leafhoppers and grasshoppers in North American crops, your state or provincial extension guide lists the products registered for each crop.

This guide covers planthoppers, leafhoppers and grasshoppers. It explains how to count them with a beat sheet or sweep net, when a spray pays, which insecticide groups are used, and how to rotate groups so the next spray still works. A calculator lets you test whether a spray covers its cost on your own field.

Which hopper are you dealing with?

“Hopper” covers three different groups of insects. They need different products, so name the pest before you choose a spray.

Hopper How it feeds Main crops Where it matters
Planthoppers Sucks sap from the stem base Rice, sugarcane, corn Asian and Pacific rice, northern Australia
Leafhoppers Sucks sap from leaves and veins Alfalfa, soybean, potato, grapes, cotton US, Canada, Europe, Australia
Grasshoppers Chews leaves, stems and heads Range, small grains, rice margins US West, Canadian Prairies, Australia

Planthoppers (family Delphacidae) and leafhoppers (family Cicadellidae) are true bugs with sucking mouthparts. Grasshoppers chew. A product that works on a chewing grasshopper by contact may do little against a planthopper that sits deep in the rice canopy, and a systemic product made for sap feeders may not suit grasshoppers.

Brown planthopper

The brown planthopper, Nilaparvata lugens, is the main planthopper pest of rice. Adults and nymphs cluster at the base of rice stems and suck sap. Heavy feeding causes “hopperburn”: round patches where plants turn yellow, then brown, and collapse. The pest also spreads virus diseases of rice. It migrates on the wind over long distances; researchers report brown planthoppers that fly into Japan each year from the mainland.

Leafhoppers in our main crops

In North American field crops the best-known leafhopper is the potato leafhopper, Empoasca fabae. Iowa State University describes it as a pest of alfalfa that removes plant juices and causes yellowing, stunting and the loss of seedling alfalfa. It is an occasional soybean pest, often near alfalfa fields. In California rice, UC IPM lists the aster leafhopper among the invertebrates to manage.

A newer arrival is the two-spot cotton leafhopper, Amrasca biguttula. The University of Florida reports it in Alabama, Florida, Georgia, Mississippi, North Carolina, South Carolina and Texas, as well as Puerto Rico and Australia. It feeds on cotton, okra, eggplant and ornamentals, and UF/IFAS researchers are testing conventional and biological insecticides against it.

Grasshoppers

Grasshoppers build up on grassy field edges, levees and rangeland, then move into crops. In Arkansas rice, the University of Arkansas rice handbook says short-horned grasshoppers are found near field margins and on levees, and advises treating where damage is evident; a border treatment may be beneficial.

Are planthoppers pests?

Many planthopper species live on wild plants and do no harm to crops. A few are serious pests. The brown planthopper and the white-backed planthopper attack rice, the corn planthopper attacks corn and sorghum, and other species spread plant viruses. The spotted lanternfly, now present in many eastern US states, is also a planthopper, though it feeds on trees and vines rather than rice.

Planthoppers become a problem when three things line up: a large migration or local build-up, a dense, well-fed crop, and few natural enemies. Broad-spectrum sprays applied early in the season can remove spiders, mirid bugs and other predators that keep planthoppers in check, which is one reason researchers link heavy spraying to later outbreaks.

Planthopper life cycle

Females lay eggs inside leaf sheaths or leaf tissue. Nymphs hatch, feed and moult several times before becoming adults. Some adults have short wings and stay in the field; others have long wings and fly off to new fields. When the crop is crowded or ageing, more long-winged adults appear. Because generations overlap, a field can hold eggs, nymphs and adults at the same time, so one spray rarely hits every stage.

How to scout hoppers with a beat sheet or sweep net

A spray decision starts with a count. Pick the tool that fits the crop and row spacing, sample several spots across the field, and write the numbers down so you can compare them next week.

The beat sheet (drop cloth) method

A beat sheet, also called a drop cloth or shake sheet, is a piece of heavy white or black cloth held flat between two rows. The University of Tennessee describes a cloth about 2.5 to 3 feet long with 42-inch dowels on each side. You kneel between two rows, bend the plants on each side over the cloth and shake them hard, then count the insects quickly before they jump or fly.

  • A three-foot cloth sampled on both rows gives a six-foot subsample.
  • Take at least four subsamples per field; UT says up to eight sites for larger fields.
  • Many thresholds are written as insects per foot of row, so divide by the row length you shook.
  • The method suits rows 30 inches or wider.

The cloth works best for slow or ground-dropping insects. Adult leafhoppers and grasshoppers can fly off before you count them, so count fast and note nymphs separately.

The sweep net

For alfalfa and narrow-row crops, a 15-inch sweep net works better. Iowa State advises 20 sweeps in at least five areas of the field for alfalfa taller than six inches, then working out leafhoppers per sweep. The University of Missouri gives a similar method: 10 pendulum sweeps at five random spots, then compare the average per sweep with the threshold.

Counting in flooded rice

In flooded rice, planthoppers sit at the base of the plants near the water. Growers in Asia tap tillers over a tray or water surface and count the insects that fall. Whatever tool you use, keep the method the same each week so the counts can be compared.

When does a hopper spray pay?

An economic threshold is the count at which treating costs less than the damage you would lose by not treating. It is not fixed. For potato leafhopper in alfalfa, Iowa State publishes tables adapted from Tooker (2013) in which the threshold falls as hay value rises and rises as control cost goes up.

Chart

Potato leafhopper threshold in alfalfa vs hay value

Leafhoppers per sweep at which treatment pays, control cost US$14 per acre, by alfalfa height

0.000.150.300.450.60$120$140$220$260$300$340$400Alfalfa 4-8 in 0.15Alfalfa under 4 in 0.13Source: Iowa State University Integrated Crop Management, Potato Leafhopper (Tables 1 and 2, adapted from Tooker 2013).
0.000.150.300.450.60$120$220$300$400Alfalfa under 4 inAlfalfa 4-8 in0.150.13Source: Iowa State University Integrated Crop Management,Potato Leafhopper (Tables 1 and 2, adapted from Tooker 2013).
The higher the hay value, the fewer leafhoppers it takes before a spray pays.

For example, at a control cost of US$14 per acre, the threshold for alfalfa under 4 inches tall falls from 0.37 leafhoppers per sweep at a hay value of US$120 per ton to 0.13 at US$400 per ton. Taller alfalfa tolerates more hoppers: for 8 to 12-inch alfalfa the threshold at US$120 hay and US$14 control is 1.73 per sweep.

Iowa State also gives soybean thresholds: treat vegetative soybean when leafhoppers exceed two per plant, flowering soybean at one per trifoliate leaf, and pod-setting soybean (R3 to R6) at two per trifoliate leaf. If alfalfa is due to be cut within about a week, cutting early is often cheaper than a foliar spray.

For grasshoppers in rice, the Arkansas rice handbook does not give a count; it says to treat when damage is evident and to watch borders near grassy areas. For brown planthopper, rice programmes in Asia use a count per hill that changes with crop stage and the number of natural enemies, so check the local guide.

Use the calculator below to test the same logic on your own field. Enter your expected loss if you do nothing, the share of that loss a spray would prevent, and your full cost per acre.

Best insecticide for brown planthopper

No single product is “best” everywhere. What works depends on how resistant the local population is. Brown planthopper has a long record of resistance, so the best choice is usually a group the population has not been pushed on.

Chart

Brown planthopper resistance in China, 2020 vs 2023

Average resistance ratio (fold) of field populations, ten provinces and Shanghai

202020230.075.0150.0225.0300.0Triflumezopyrim2.57.1Nitenpyram18.337.7Dinotefuran119.5268.1Source: Pesticide Biochemistry and Physiology (2024), BPH resistance monitoring 2020-2023, abstract via Europe PMC.
202020230.075.0150.0225.0300.0Triflumezopyrim2.57.1Nitenpyram18.337.7Dinotefuran119.5268.1Source: Pesticide Biochemistry and Physiology (2024), BPHresistance monitoring 2020-2023, abstract via Europe PMC.
Resistance rose for all three; triflumezopyrim remained low.

What the resistance studies show

A survey published in Pest Management Science (2016) tested brown planthoppers collected across South and East Asia from 2005 to 2012. It found up to 220-fold resistance to imidacloprid and 223-fold resistance to ethiprole. The same paper cites 617-fold imidacloprid resistance recorded in China in 2012, 616-fold in planthoppers flying into Japan, and 308.5-fold ethiprole resistance in Thailand. It links imidacloprid resistance to overexpression of the enzyme CYP6ER1.

Newer monitoring in China, published in Pesticide Biochemistry and Physiology (2024), covered ten provinces and Shanghai from 2020 to 2023. The average resistance ratio to triflumezopyrim rose from 2.5 to 7.1-fold, nitenpyram from 18.3 to 37.7-fold and dinotefuran from 119.5 to 268.1-fold. All populations kept extremely high resistance to imidacloprid, thiamethoxam and buprofezin. Most had moderate resistance to chlorpyrifos and sulfoxaflor, and high resistance to pymetrozine when tested by rice stem dipping.

A resistance ratio compares the dose that kills half of a field population with the dose that kills half of a susceptible lab strain. A ratio of 7 means the field insects need about seven times the dose. Low ratios are good news; rising ratios are a warning to rotate.

Insecticide groups used on planthoppers

The Insecticide Resistance Action Committee (IRAC) sorts insecticides by mode of action. Products in the same group act on the same target, so rotating within a group does not slow resistance.

IRAC group Examples What the studies show for BPH
4A neonicotinoids Imidacloprid, thiamethoxam, dinotefuran, nitenpyram Very high resistance to imidacloprid and thiamethoxam; dinotefuran rising fast (China, 2020-2023)
4C sulfoximines Sulfoxaflor Moderate resistance in most Chinese populations
4E mesoionics Triflumezopyrim Low but rising (2.5 to 7.1-fold average)
9B Pymetrozine, pyrifluquinazon High by stem dip; results depend on the test method
16 Buprofezin Extremely high resistance in China
2B phenylpyrazoles Ethiprole, fipronil Up to 223-fold (Asia) and 308.5-fold (Thailand) for ethiprole

Group 4E is a separate subgroup from 4A in the IRAC scheme. Even so, rotate it with groups outside 4, and do not use it on back-to-back generations. Registrations differ by country and crop: a product used on rice in one country may not be labelled for that use where you farm.

A simple rotation plan

A rotation plan is easier to follow if you write it before the season starts. Think in windows of about one hopper generation, which in warm weather can be a few weeks. Use one IRAC group per window, then move to a different group for the next window, even if the first spray seemed to work well.

  • Window 1: no spray unless counts pass the threshold. Let predators build up.
  • Window 2: if needed, a product from a group with low local resistance.
  • Window 3: if needed again, a product from a different group, not the one used in window 2.
  • Next season: start with the group you used least this season.

Mixtures sold as one product often contain two active ingredients from different groups. Count both groups in your plan. If the label lists group 3A and 4A, for example, you have used both groups in that window.

Signs a spray is failing

Check the field three to five days after spraying. If you still find many live nymphs at the stem base, or hopperburn patches keep spreading, the spray may not have reached the insects or the local population may be resistant. Before you spray again, check the rate, water volume and coverage. If those were right, switch to a different IRAC group and report the result to your extension office, which may track resistance in your area.

How to get more from each spray

  • Aim at the stem base. Planthoppers feed low in the canopy, so use enough water volume to reach it.
  • Spray nymphs early. Large adult populations near harvest are harder to control.
  • Do not spray before the threshold. Early broad-spectrum sprays can remove predators and lead to later outbreaks.
  • Do not mix two products from the same group as a “boost”.
  • Record the product, group, rate and date for each field.

Always read and follow the product label, check which products are registered for your crop and region, and ask your local extension service or a licensed crop adviser before you spray.

Chart

Highest brown planthopper resistance ratios reported

Fold resistance of field populations, as reported or cited in one 2016 study (Japan figure compares 2012 with 1992 populations; fipronil is the top of a 23.8-43.3 range)

0.0200.0400.0600.0800.0Imidacloprid, China 2012617.0Imidacloprid, Japan616.0Ethiprole, Thailand308.5Ethiprole, Asia survey223.0Imidacloprid, Asia survey220.0Fipronil, China43.3Source: Garrood et al., Pest Management Science (2016), survey of 2005-2012 collections and cited studies.
0.0200.0400.0600.0800.0Imidacloprid, China 2012617.0Imidacloprid, Japan616.0Ethiprole, Thailand308.5Ethiprole, Asia survey223.0Imidacloprid, Asia survey220.0Fipronil, China43.3Source: Garrood et al., Pest Management Science (2016), surveyof 2005-2012 collections and cited studies.
Imidacloprid resistance passed 600-fold in China and in planthoppers reaching Japan by 2012.

Best insecticide for hoppers in North American crops

Leafhoppers in alfalfa and soybean

Iowa State’s first option for potato leafhopper in alfalfa is often not a spray at all: if harvest is due within a week, cut early. Alfalfa-oat mixtures tend to carry fewer leafhoppers than pure alfalfa, and lady beetles, predatory bugs and lacewings feed on adults and nymphs. When counts pass the threshold and harvest is not near, a labelled foliar insecticide is the next step. Your state’s field crop insect guide lists the products and rates.

Grasshoppers in rice and field borders

The Arkansas rice handbook lists lambda-cyhalothrin and zeta-cypermethrin (pyrethroids, IRAC group 3A) among the treatments for short-horned grasshoppers in rice. Because grasshoppers move in from grassy borders, the handbook says a border treatment may be beneficial. The same handbook warns that broad-spectrum sprays can upset the natural balance of rice insects, so treat only where damage is evident.

Protecting bees and natural enemies

Many hopper insecticides are toxic to bees. UC IPM keeps bee precaution ratings for each active ingredient, with group codes, so you can choose a product and timing that lower the risk. Spraying when bees are not foraging and avoiding flowering weeds in the field help too. UC IPM also publishes the relative toxicity of rice pesticides to natural enemies and honey bees.

Integrated hopper management

Integrated pest management (IPM) means using several tools together so you need fewer sprays. For hoppers it rests on five steps.

  1. Prevent. Use tolerant or resistant varieties where they exist, keep nitrogen to what the crop needs, and manage grassy borders.
  2. Scout. Count with a beat sheet, sweep net or tap tray every week while the risk is high.
  3. Decide. Compare counts with the local threshold and check predator numbers.
  4. Act. Cut early, treat borders or spray a labelled product only where counts pass the threshold.
  5. Rotate and record. Change IRAC group between generations and keep spray records.

For more on setting thresholds, see our guide to action thresholds and when pest control is truly needed. If you are weighing biological options against conventional sprays, our page on sustainable vs organic farming explains how the two approaches differ.

Biological and cultural options

Spiders, mirid bugs, lady beetles, egg parasitoids and fungi such as Metarhizium attack planthoppers and leafhoppers. Keeping them alive is part of control. Avoid early broad-spectrum sprays, leave some flowering field edges where it suits your farm, and avoid dense, over-fertilised crops that hoppers prefer. In alfalfa, timely cutting removes much of the leafhopper population with the hay.

A light-hearted look at how satellite maps show crop stress across a large farm.

โ–ถ A light-hearted look at how satellite maps show crop stress across a large farm. ยท 4:09

Using satellite crop maps to target scouting

Satellites cannot count hoppers. They can show where crop growth is falling behind the rest of the field, which helps you decide where to walk first. Hopperburn, leafhopper yellowing and grasshopper feeding all lower plant vigour, and vegetation index maps such as NDVI show that change across the whole field.

Farmonaut is a satellite and AI farm monitoring system. You draw your field once, and it maps vegetation indices for each new satellite image through the season, on the web or on Android and iOS. A patch that weakens between images is a place to check with a beat sheet or sweep net. The map does not say which pest is there; the field count does.

How to read NDVI maps and spot crop stress early on your own field.

โ–ถ How to read NDVI maps and spot crop stress early on your own field. ยท 19:36

Insecticide spray break-even calculator

This calculator compares the value of the yield a spray would save with the full cost of the spray. Every value is your own input. The defaults are round example numbers set close to break-even, not benchmarks.

Try the numbers for your own farm below.

Calculator

Does a hopper spray pay on your field?

Enter your own yield, price, expected loss and spray cost.

acres

units/acre

US$/unit

%

%

US$/acre
0US$ net gain from spraying the field (negative means the spray costs more than it saves)
  • Value saved per acre: 17 US$
  • Spray cost per acre: 17 US$
  • Loss needed to break even: 5 %

Example values only, set near break-even; they are not benchmarks. Use today’s crop price and your own quote for product and application. Expected loss and spray efficacy are your estimates from field counts and local advice. Check the label and local rules, and get professional advice before spraying.

How we checked the numbers

Thresholds come from Iowa State University and the University of Missouri. Resistance figures come from two peer-reviewed papers: Garrood and colleagues in Pest Management Science (2016) and the 2024 Chinese monitoring study in Pesticide Biochemistry and Physiology. Insecticide groups follow the IRAC mode of action classification. Rice and grasshopper advice comes from the University of Arkansas rice handbook and UC IPM. Beat sheet methods come from the University of Tennessee. Product registrations change, so check your local label before use.

Related pages on our site: fertilizer optimization ยท carbon footprinting ยท crop loans and insurance ยท product traceability ยท fleet management ยท large farm management ยท weather API docs ยท satellite data API ยท web app ยท Android app ยท iOS app

FAQ

What is the best insecticide for brown planthopper?

It depends on local resistance. Chinese monitoring from 2020 to 2023 found low but rising resistance to triflumezopyrim (2.5 to 7.1-fold on average) and extremely high resistance to imidacloprid, thiamethoxam and buprofezin. Use a product registered for rice in your country, and rotate IRAC groups between generations.

Are planthoppers pests?

Some are. Most planthopper species feed on wild plants, but the brown planthopper and white-backed planthopper damage rice, the corn planthopper attacks corn and sorghum, and several species spread plant viruses.

What insecticide kills hoppers in alfalfa?

For potato leafhopper, Iowa State advises cutting early if harvest is within a week. If counts pass the threshold and harvest is further away, use a foliar insecticide labelled for alfalfa from your state’s insect control guide.

How do you use a beat sheet?

Lay the cloth between two rows, bend the plants on each side over it, shake them hard and count the insects quickly. Take at least four subsamples per field and convert counts to insects per foot of row.

Why do planthoppers come back after spraying?

Resistant insects survive, new adults fly in, and eggs inside leaf sheaths hatch after the spray. Early broad-spectrum sprays can also kill the predators that would have kept numbers down.

Authored by: Farmonaut Research & Content Team

Reviewed and verified by: Farmonaut Agricultural Experts Team

Reviewed November 2026 against the IRAC mode of action classification, peer-reviewed brown planthopper resistance studies in Pest Management Science (2016) and Pesticide Biochemistry and Physiology (2024), and extension guidance from Iowa State, Missouri, Florida, Arkansas, Tennessee and UC IPM.

Farmonaut crop monitoring

Know where to scout first

Draw your fields once and Farmonaut maps crop vigour from each new satellite image, on web, Android or iOS, so you can walk weak patches first.

Open The Farmonaut Crop Monitoring Web AppGet The Farmonaut App On Google PlayGet The Farmonaut App On The App Store
Farmonaut Web App With A Satellite Crop Health Map

Sources

  1. Garrood et al., Field-evolved resistance to imidacloprid and ethiprole in brown planthopper populations from South and East Asia, Pest Management Science (2016): ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
  2. Resistance monitoring of brown planthopper to nine insecticides in China, 2020-2023, Pesticide Biochemistry and Physiology (2024), Europe PMC record: ebi.ac.uk
  3. IRAC, Mode of Action Classification (online): irac-online.org
  4. Iowa State University Integrated Crop Management, Potato Leafhopper: crops.extension.iastate.edu
  5. University of Missouri IPM, Potato Leafhopper Numbers Increasing in Alfalfa Fields: ipm.missouri.edu
  6. University of Florida IFAS, Two-Spot Cotton Leafhopper Amrasca biguttula (EENY-827): ask.ifas.ufl.edu
  7. University of Arkansas, Arkansas Rice Production Handbook MP192, Chapter 12 Insect Management in Rice: uaex.uada.edu
  8. University of Tennessee UT Crops, Drop Cloth (Shake Sheet) Sampling: utcrops.com
  9. UC Statewide IPM Program, Bee Precaution Pesticide Ratings: ipm.ucanr.edu
  10. UC Statewide IPM Program, Rice Pest Management Guidelines: ipm.ucanr.edu
  11. IRAC, MoA classification documents: irac-online.org
  12. Android app: play.google.com
  13. iOS app: apps.apple.com


Discussion

Questions, corrections or field experience? Share them below. First-time comments are reviewed before they appear, and your email is never published.

No comments yet. Be the first to add a question or your experience.

Leave a comment

Farmonaut Farmonaut Trusted by 200,000+ users and 100+ businesses 200,000+ users trust us Get started