Underground mining methods ยท Animated guide
Sublevel Stoping Animation: 3 Methods, Steps and Costs
Sublevel stoping blasts long holes from stacked tunnels into an open stope; shrinkage stoping mines upward on its own broken ore; sublevel caving lets the roof fall in. Here is what each animation shows and what each costs per tonne.

Key takeaways
- Sublevel open stoping blasts ore with long holes from stacked sublevels into an open stope, mucks it from drawpoints and then backfills (Penn State MNG 230).
- Shrinkage stoping mines steep veins upward; about 40% of the broken ore is drawn during mining and the rest at the end.
- In one modelled comparison, sublevel longhole stoping cost US$19.02/t at 4,000 t/day against US$51.49/t for shrinkage at 1,000 t/day (Kliche, 2017).
- Sublevel caving mines downward and lets the surface subside; LKAB mines Kiirunavaara this way, and Kiruna’s centre is moving about 3 km east.
- Santa Rita in Brazil chose sublevel caving over SLOS options in its 2020 study, citing mining costs below US$20/t.
In this article
- What These Animations Show, and Why They Differ
- Shrinkage Stoping: Core Principles and Stope Development
- Shrinkage Stoping Mining Method Animation: Process Steps
- Ground Control and Safety in Shrinkage Stoping Operations
- Sublevel Open Stoping Animation: The Methodical Variant
- Where Sublevel Caving Fits (and Where It Doesn't)
- Comparison Table: Shrinkage vs. Sublevel Open Stoping vs. Sublevel Caving
- Calculator: Estimate Stoping Cost per Tonne for Your Project
- Why Mining Companies Use Animation for Training and Planning
- Choosing a Method: Geometry, Stability, and Surface Conditions
- Satellite Intelligence Before You Commit to a Stoping Plan
- Environmental Considerations and Site Rehabilitation
- Frequently asked questions
- Conclusion & Further Resources
A sublevel stoping animation shows ore being blasted with long drill holes from a stack of horizontal tunnels (sublevels) into an open room, called a stope, and then mucked out from its base. A shrinkage stoping animation shows the opposite build-up: miners blast a steep vein from the bottom upward and stand on their own broken ore, drawing off only part of it after each blast. A sublevel caving animation shows the roof rock collapsing on purpose behind each blasted ring. In one published cost comparison, sublevel longhole stoping ran at about US$19 per tonne against about US$51 per tonne for shrinkage stoping (Kliche, Resolution Copper EIS memo, 2017). This guide walks through what each animation shows, step by step, and how the three methods compare on cost, scale, recovery and safety.
A few terms first. A stope is the opening left after ore is mined underground. The hanging wall is the rock above a dipping ore body and the footwall is the rock below it. Dip is the angle of the ore body from horizontal. Dilution is waste rock that gets mixed into the ore, and recovery is the share of the ore in the ground that actually reaches the mill.
What These Animations Show, and Why They Differ
Search results for “open stope mining animation”, “shrinkage stoping animation” and “sublevel caving animation” often look alike in thumbnails: a cut-away block of rock, a yellow drill rig and a pile of broken ore. They are showing three different answers to one question: what holds the rock up while the ore comes out?
The Penn State introductory mining-engineering course groups underground methods into three classes: unsupported, supported and caving methods, and says the choice reflects how strong the ore and the surrounding rock are (Penn State MNG 230). Shrinkage stoping and sublevel open stoping both sit in the unsupported family: the walls must stand on their own for a while. Sublevel caving is in the caving family: it only works if the hanging wall breaks and flows in behind the miners.
- Shrinkage stoping: the void is mostly full of broken ore until the last stage, so the animation shows a rising pile with a thin working gap above it.
- Sublevel open stoping: the void is mostly empty, so the animation shows a tall open room, rings of long blast holes and loaders working from drawpoints at the bottom, followed by backfill.
- Sublevel caving: the void never stays open, so the animation shows mining moving downward level by level, with caved waste filling in from above.
That is why one clip cannot fairly stand in for all three. If you are using an animation to train staff or brief an investor, pick the one that matches the method in the mine plan, then check that its sequence matches the steps below.
Shrinkage Stoping: Core Principles and Stope Development
Shrinkage stoping is used for steep ore bodies, typically dipping about 70 to 90 degrees, where mining goes upward in horizontal slices and the broken ore stays in the stope as a working floor (Wikipedia, Stoping). The Resolution Copper alternatives memo gives a wider limit: a dip of more than 55 degrees, steeper than the angle of repose so broken ore can be drawn, with strong ore (Kliche, 2017).
The name comes from swell. Broken rock takes up more space than solid rock, so after each blast some ore must be drawn from the bottom to keep a gap for the next slice. Penn State describes this drawing-off as the “shrinkage” of the stope. Roughly 40% of the blasted ore is removed during mining, and the rest stays in place until the stope reaches its top (Wikipedia, Stoping).
- Selective: short drill holes follow the vein closely, which helps keep dilution down in narrow veins.
- Low mechanization: the method relies on hand-held or small drills, so it suits small mines with modest capital.
- Ore as temporary support: the muck pile pushes against the walls while mining goes on, but it is not engineered fill.
- Crown and sill pillars: slabs of solid rock are left above and below the stope to protect the levels.
Shrinkage Stoping Animation: Phases and Ore Handling
A good shrinkage animation shows six stages in this order:
- Development: a haulage drive is driven along the bottom of the block, with drawpoints or chutes below the planned stope and a raise at each end for access and air.
- Undercut: the first slice is blasted above the drawpoints to open the stope.
- Breaking slices: miners stand on the broken ore, drill short upward holes into the back and blast the next slice.
- Drawing the swell: loaders or chutes remove about the swell volume from below, leaving a gap of roughly head height for the next round.
- Reaching the crown: mining stops below the crown pillar that protects the level above.
- Final draw: all remaining ore is drawn, and the empty stope is backfilled or left open depending on ground conditions.
The single image that defines the method is the muck pile rising with the face. If the animation shows an empty room with miners on a floor of solid rock, it is showing a different method.
Shrinkage Stoping Backfill: Role and Mechanics
During mining, the broken ore does the job that fill does in other methods: it keeps loose slabs from peeling off the walls. It is a temporary arrangement. Once the ore is shrunk off, the stope is empty. It may then be backfilled or left empty, depending on rock conditions (Wikipedia, Stoping).
The same memo lists two practical drawbacks. A large share of the ore is tied up in the stope as inventory until the final draw, which delays revenue. And where there is water, broken sulphide ore left in the stope can oxidize.
Shrinkage Stoping Mining Method Animation: Process Steps
For a planner, the animation is useful only if each step maps to a task with a time and a cost. Here is the same sequence as a work list.
- Stope preparation and access: drive the haulage level, raises and drawpoints; design crown and sill pillar thickness from the rock-mass rating (a score of rock strength and jointing).
- Undercut and first slice: blast the first slice above the drawpoints and check that broken ore flows to every drawpoint.
- Cyclic mining: drill, charge, blast, ventilate, scale loose rock and draw the swell, then repeat each shift.
- Grade control: sample the face after each slice so the stope boundary follows the vein and does not cut into barren wall rock.
- Final draw: draw all broken ore once the crown is reached, watching for hung-up ore and uneven flow.
- Close-out: fill or seal the stope and record it on the mine plan so later workings stay clear of it.
Vein width matters at step 1: the true width of the vein, not the apparent width seen in a drill hole, decides whether miners can work safely between the walls. Our guide to strike length and true width explains how to convert drill intercepts into the width a stope will actually have.
โถ How gold ore is mined and processed, from rock to bar, step by step ยท 5:27
Ground Control and Safety in Shrinkage Stoping Operations
Because miners work directly under freshly blasted rock, shrinkage stoping places heavy demands on scaling (barring down loose rock) and on support. In the United States, metal and nonmetal underground mines must correct hazardous ground conditions before other work starts in the affected area, or post the area and keep people out (30 CFR 57.3200). Where ground conditions or experience in similar ground show it is needed, support must be designed, installed and maintained to control the ground where people work or travel (30 CFR 57.3360).
- Scaling and inspection: every work place is examined before and during each shift, because the back is new rock after each blast.
- Bolting the walls and back: rock bolts or split sets are used where joints or weak bands could release slabs.
- Pillar design: crown and sill pillar thickness is checked against rock strength and stope span.
- Ventilation: fresh air must reach a narrow working gap above the muck pile, and the stope must be cleared of blast fumes before re-entry.
- Uneven draw: pulling too much from one drawpoint can leave a void under the working floor, which is why draw is recorded by drawpoint.
Animations help here by showing crews where the gap, the drawpoints and the escape raise are. Our overview of mine safety technology covers the monitoring tools that sit on top of these basics.
Sublevel Open Stoping Animation: The Methodical Variant
Sublevel open stoping, also called sublevel longhole stoping or SLOS, is the method most “open stope mining animation” clips show. Penn State describes it as a versatile, productive method for large, steep ore bodies with a regular shape and defined boundaries, in which large stopes are blasted out between sublevels and usually backfilled to raise recovery (Penn State MNG 230).
Chart
Modelled production rate by underground method
Tonnes of ore per day, shaft-access mine model
Sublevel stoping animation, step by step
- Sublevels and drill drives: horizontal drifts are driven through the ore at set vertical intervals.
- Slot raise: an opening raise is cut at one end of the stope to give the first blast room to expand.
- Long-hole drilling: rings or fans of long holes are drilled from the sublevels; if the rock allows, the whole stope is drilled before charging.
- Blasting in sections: slices are blasted into the open slot, and each blast makes room for a larger one.
- Mucking from the base: loaders, often remote-controlled, pull broken ore from drawpoints at the bottom so nobody enters the open stope.
- Backfill: the empty stope is filled, often with tailings sand or cemented fill, so the next stope beside it can be mined.
Penn State notes that mines often split the ore into primary and secondary stopes. Primary stopes are mined and filled with stabilized fill first; the secondary stopes between them are left as pillars until then, and cable bolts are often installed above secondary stopes before they are mined. Because many stopes on different levels can run at once, the method keeps productivity high with low dilution.
Where it fits and what it needs
- Ore body: steep, wide enough for long-hole rings, with clean contacts.
- Rock: strong ore and strong walls, because the stope stands open while it is mucked.
- Fill plant: a supply of tailings or paste fill for high recovery.
- Capital: a mechanized fleet of long-hole drills and loaders.
Scale is the main difference from shrinkage stoping. In the Resolution memo’s cost table, sublevel longhole stoping is sized at 4,000 tonnes per day against 1,000 tonnes per day for shrinkage. At the Santa Rita nickel mine in Brazil, Appian’s 2021 analysis estimated a maximum of about 4.5 million tonnes per year for the SLOS options it studied, below the sublevel caving case (Appian Capital Advisory, March 2021).
Where Sublevel Caving Fits (and Where It Doesn’t)
A sublevel caving animation starts at the top of the ore body and moves down. Penn State describes a large-scale method for steep ore bodies where the hanging wall rock will fracture under control, with all infrastructure on the footwall side. Production drifts are driven and supported, long holes are drilled in ring patterns, and after each ring is blasted the ore is loaded from the cave front while caved waste follows from above (Penn State MNG 230).
The key control in the animation is the draw: loaders take a set percentage of each ring, then move on, so that waste from the cave does not flood the ore. Appian describes modern practice as drawing evenly from all drawpoints using tonnages set by computer modelling for each ring, which leaves a blanket of waste above the ore (Appian, 2021).
The cave reaches the surface. That is the trade-off. The best-known example is LKAB’s Kiirunavaara mine in Sweden, which LKAB says is mined by sublevel caving and, with Malmberget, is one of the world’s two largest underground iron ore mines (LKAB). The mine has used sublevel caving since the 1960s and produced 26.9 million tonnes of iron ore in 2018 (Wikipedia, Kiruna Mine). Because the mine undermines the old town, Kiruna’s centre is being moved about 3 km east (Wikipedia, Kiruna).
Santa Rita: a stoping-versus-caving decision in practice
Atlantic Nickel’s Santa Rita mine in Bahia, Brazil, is a useful case because both methods were studied. Its 2020 preliminary economic assessment chose sublevel caving for about 134 million tonnes of underground material, extending mine life from 8 to 34 years, with US$355 million of capital over the first five years, underground development planned from 2026 and first production in 2028 (Appian, Santa Rita PEA release). Appian put the sublevel cave’s mining cost below US$20 per tonne and its net smelter return (the ore’s value after smelting and refining charges) at US$46 per tonne at US$6.50/lb nickel and US$3.00/lb copper; the SLOS options showed lower margins and a lower production rate. Those are study-stage figures at 2021 prices, not results.
Comparison Table: Shrinkage vs. Sublevel Open Stoping vs. Sublevel Caving
The cost figures below come from one table in the Resolution Copper alternatives memo, which drew on a mining cost service for a shaft-access underground mine. They are model estimates in 2010 US dollars (an Edumine table built from CostMine’s Mining Cost Service), not current quotes, but they compare the methods on the same basis.
Chart
Modelled operating cost per tonne by method
US$ per tonne of ore (2010 dollars), shaft-access mine model
| Factor | Shrinkage stoping | Sublevel open stoping | Sublevel caving |
|---|---|---|---|
| Method class | Unsupported (ore as temporary support) | Unsupported, then backfilled | Caving |
| Typical dip | More than 55 degrees; 70 to 90 typical | Steep, regular | Steep, large |
| Rock needed | Fairly strong ore and walls | Strong ore and walls | Hanging wall that caves under control |
| Mining direction | Upward | Stope by stope, between sublevels | Downward, level by level |
| Modelled rate | 1,000 t/day | 4,000 t/day | 8,000 t/day |
| Modelled operating cost | US$51.49/t | US$19.02/t | US$21.99/t |
| Modelled capital cost | US$31.5 million | US$63.7 million | US$142.6 million |
| Main risk | Ore tied up in stope; oxidation; work under fresh back | Wall failure into open stope; fill supply | Dilution from caved waste; surface subsidence |
| Surface effect | Little if stopes are filled | Little if stopes are filled | Subsidence is expected |
Source for the rate and cost rows: Table 2 in Kliche (2017). The same table puts cut-and-fill at US$68.03/t and block caving at US$9.10/t, and the memo notes that cut-and-fill can cost 20 or more times as much per tonne as block caving.
Two points stand out. Shrinkage stoping is the cheapest to set up but the most expensive per tonne, because it is small and labour-intensive. Sublevel caving needs more than twice the capital of the stoping option in the table, which pays off only with a large ore body and a surface that can subside.
Calculator: Estimate Stoping Cost per Tonne for Your Project
Use the calculator to test one stope. Enter the stope size, your own mining and fill costs, development spent on the stope and an example ore value. The share drawn during mining matters for shrinkage stopes: the rest of the broken ore sits in the stope as unsold inventory until the final draw. For sublevel open stoping, set the share drawn to 100.
Calculator
What does one stope cost, and how much ore is tied up?
Enter your own stope size, costs and an example ore value.
- Margin per tonne (US$): 47.00
- Stope margin (US$): $940,000
- Ore held in the stope until final draw (tonnes): 12,000
- Value held in the stope (US$): $1,440,000
Example values only, not a benchmark or a forecast. Ore value is an input: example, use today’s price and your own net smelter return. Ignores ventilation, dewatering, overhead, taxes and recovery losses. Use US$ throughout.
Why Mining Companies Use Animation for Training and Planning
Animations are cheap compared with a mistake underground. They are used in four ways.
- Training: new staff see the sequence and the danger zones (open stope edges, drawpoints, the working gap) before they go underground.
- Design review: engineers step through drilling, blasting and draw to spot clashes, such as a drawpoint placed under a weak zone.
- Scheduling: showing several stopes at once makes it clear which primary stopes must be filled before secondary stopes can be blasted.
- Explaining to owners and investors: a short clip shows why a project picked a method, which helps when a study compares options, as the Santa Rita study did.
Epiroc’s series of mining-method animations, which Penn State uses in its course for room and pillar, sublevel stoping, cut and fill, block caving and sublevel caving, is a common starting point. A site-specific animation built on the mine’s own block model is far more useful for design review.
Choosing a Method: Geometry, Stability, and Surface Conditions
Most method selection comes down to five questions.
Chart
Capital cost against operating cost
Capital in US$ million (x) and operating cost in US$ per tonne (y), shaft-access model
- How steep and how wide is the ore? Narrow steep veins point to shrinkage or cut-and-fill; wide steep bodies to sublevel stoping or caving; flat beds to room and pillar.
- How strong are the ore and walls? Strong rock allows open stopes; weak walls rule them out; a hanging wall that caves well is the starting condition for caving.
- Can the surface subside? If there are towns, roads, rivers or another operation above, caving is unlikely to be allowed without major work, as Kiruna shows.
- What tonnage and grade? Higher grade carries higher cost per tonne; low grade needs bulk methods.
- How much capital is there? In the cost table, shrinkage needs about a fifth of the capital of sublevel caving.
For a wider look at how costs and grade combine into margin, see our guide to mining profitability, and for who does this design work, our overview of a mine development company.
Satellite Intelligence Before You Commit to a Stoping Plan
Mining method is chosen after drilling has defined the ore body, but satellite data can help earlier, when a consultant is deciding where to drill. Multispectral imagery maps alteration minerals, iron oxides and faults at the surface, which helps rank targets before money goes into drill holes. Farmonaut offers satellite-based mineral detection for this screening stage; it does not replace drilling or a mine design. You can request a mining quote or contact the team to discuss a site.
โถ What Farmonaut Mining Pro does before drilling starts ยท 4:56
Environmental Considerations and Site Rehabilitation
The three methods leave different footprints at closure.
- Stopes left open: unfilled stopes can collapse long after mining ends, and when old records are lost these voids become an unexpected surface hazard.
- Backfilled stopes: putting tailings back underground as fill reduces the tailings stored at surface and supports the ground; Penn State notes that tailings sand from the plant can be reused as fill.
- Caving: subsidence is part of the plan, so closure must deal with a permanent crater or depression and with any changes to surface water. Appian argues that sublevel caving has a smaller surface footprint than an open pit, since no waste stripping is needed.
- Sulphide ore: broken sulphide left in shrinkage stopes can oxidize, which matters for water quality as well as safety.
Satellite images taken over years are a simple way to track subsidence, waste dumps and rehabilitation at a closed or operating site.
โถ The main environmental impacts of mining, explained ยท 2:31
Frequently asked questions
What does a sublevel stoping animation show?
It shows horizontal sublevels driven through a steep ore body, an opening slot raise, rings of long blast holes, ore blasted into a large open stope and loaded from drawpoints at the base, and then backfill so the next stope can be mined.
What does a shrinkage stoping animation show?
It shows a steep vein mined from the bottom upward, with miners standing on broken ore. About 40% of the blasted ore is drawn during mining to make room for the next slice, and the rest is drawn once the stope reaches the crown pillar.
What is the difference between sublevel stoping and sublevel caving?
Sublevel stoping keeps the stope open and then fills it, so the surface is protected. Sublevel caving mines from the top down and lets the hanging wall cave in behind each blasted ring, so the surface subsides.
Why is it called shrinkage stoping?
Broken rock swells, so some ore must be drawn off after each blast to keep a working gap. Removing that swell is the “shrinkage” of the stope.
Is open stoping the same as sublevel open stoping?
Open stoping is the wider family in which ore is removed as soon as it is broken and the stope stays open. Sublevel stoping and big-hole stoping are its main modern versions.
Which is cheaper per tonne, shrinkage or sublevel stoping?
In the Resolution Copper alternatives memo, shrinkage stoping was modelled at US$51.49 per tonne at 1,000 tonnes per day and sublevel longhole stoping at US$19.02 per tonne at 4,000 tonnes per day. Real costs depend on the site.
What dip is needed for shrinkage stoping?
Steep: sources give more than 55 degrees (Kliche, 2017) or 70 to 90 degrees (Wikipedia), so that broken ore flows down to the drawpoints under gravity.
Which mines use sublevel caving?
LKAB’s Kiirunavaara and Malmberget iron ore mines in Sweden are the best-known examples. Santa Rita in Brazil chose sublevel caving for its planned underground mine.
What is vertical crater retreat mining?
Vertical crater retreat (VCR) is a bulk variant of open stoping, described by Penn State as a modern variant related to shrinkage stoping. Large-diameter holes are drilled through the ore, which is blasted in horizontal slices from the bottom up; it needs thick, steep ore and strong rock.
Is backfill always used in sublevel stoping?
Not always, but it is usual where high recovery is wanted, because fill lets the pillars between primary stopes be mined later as secondary stopes.
Conclusion & Further Resources
Shrinkage stoping suits narrow, steep, fairly high-grade veins in small mines, at low capital but high cost per tonne. Sublevel open stoping suits larger steep bodies in strong rock, with mechanized long-hole drilling and backfill. Sublevel caving suits large steep bodies where the surface can subside and lowest cost per tonne matters most. Watch the animation that matches the method in your plan, then test the numbers with the calculator above using your own site costs.
This page is for information only. It is not engineering, investment or legal advice. Cost figures are modelled estimates from the cited sources, not quotes.
Farmonaut mining
Map a client's project area from space
Consultants can screen ground for alteration and structure with satellite data before planning drilling and mine design.
Mining Pro sample view, synthetic data
Sources
- Penn State, MNG 230: Underground Mining Methods: courses.ems.psu.edu
- Kliche, Technical Memorandum for Alternative Mining Methods, Resolution Copper EIS record (2017): resolutionmineeis.us
- Appian Capital Advisory, Sublevel cave mining: unearthing new opportunities (March 2021): appiancapitaladvisory.com
- Appian Capital Advisory, Atlantic Nickel Santa Rita PEA release (2020): appiancapitaladvisory.com
- International Mining, Santa Rita open pit and sublevel caving plans: im-mining.com
- LKAB, Mining: lkab.com
- Wikipedia, Kiruna Mine: en.wikipedia.org
- Wikipedia, Kiruna: en.wikipedia.org
- Wikipedia, Stoping: en.wikipedia.org
- Wikipedia, Underground hard-rock mining: en.wikipedia.org
- eCFR, 30 CFR 57.3200 Correction of hazardous conditions: ecfr.gov
- eCFR, 30 CFR 57.3360 Ground support use: ecfr.gov
Discussion
Questions, corrections or field experience? Share them below. First-time comments are reviewed before they appear, and your email is never published.
No comments yet. Be the first to add a question or your experience.


Client · Oregon, USA · Gold
Exploration consultancy · South Africa · Gold
Licence holder · Niger · Gold
Licence holder · Nigeria · Gold + lithium
Client · Tanzania · Gold
Client · Somalia · Gold
Client & affiliate partner · Ghana · Gold